StandingClosedBeta

Bounty for idea #4891USD 500.00

Dennis Hackethal wanted more criticisms of this idea. The bounty has ended.

Ended

Accepted criticisms
0
Time to review each criticism
7 days
Ended on

Idea to Criticize

Our ideas can be 100% true in the sense of absolute truth. It’s possible to come up with true ideas. There’s no criterion of truth to tell that they’re true, but they can still be true.

#4891·​Dennis HackethalOP, 6 months ago

Terms

Looking for criticisms arguing the cynic view that all our ideas are necessarily false.

Site-wide terms apply. To be eligible for a payout, participants must connect a Stripe account in good standing and submit at least one direct criticism of idea #4891 meeting all bounty terms and having no pending counter-criticisms 7 days after submission. Counter-criticisms do not need to meet the bounty terms.

Submissions1

Pending criticismsReview deadline:

I think you run into the problem of definitions. An idea cannot be absolute, perfect truth without total, perfect, complete definitions for its terms. This isn't required for knowledge - the terms can be rough because the ideas are tentative. But for absolute truth, the boundaries of meaning of your terms must be completely determined. But, as the postmoderns pointed out, this requires infinite information - the complete determination of any one term requires its distinction from all other terms. In fact, they didn't go far enough. I'd argue you would need to know the distinction between the term and all other possible terms.

You have to know perfect definitions in order to have the idea in your head be perfectly true. Perfect definitions require infinite information, therefore you cannot know perfect truth.

#4892·​Rob Rosenbaum, 6 months ago