Activity Feed
unequal contest between employers and workers
This is a mistaken socialist talking point. The idea is that employers have ‘power’ over prospective employees (not ‘workers’) because the latter ‘need’ a job.
But the reality is that employers also need employees. There can be swings from a buyer’s to a seller’s market, yes, but once again (see #6125) regulators should take a look in the mirror to see if they caused any of the conditions that made it harder for people to find jobs that pay well.
Ironically, the minimum wage is itself one such regulation. And it affects industries that are already heavily regulated, such as grocery stores. Existing regulation makes it harder for new competitors to enter the market – who would otherwise have competed not just for customers but also for employees.
unequal contest between employers and workers
This is a mistaken socialist talking point. The idea is that employers have ‘power’ over prospective employees (not ‘workers’) because the latter ‘need’ a job.
But the reality is that employers also need employees. There can be swings from a buyer’s to a seller’s market and vice versa, yes, but once again (see #6125) regulators should take a look in the mirror to see if they caused any of the conditions that made it harder for people to find jobs that pay well.
Ironically, the minimum wage is itself one such regulation. And it affects industries that are already heavily regulated, such as grocery stores. Existing regulation makes it harder for new competitors to enter the market – who would otherwise have competed not just for customers but also for employees. Offering higher wages than your competition is one way to attract talent.
#6141·Dennis HackethalOP, 2 days ago·AI-assistedWages should be set by workers’ needs, not by market bargaining. Left to the market, wages come out of an unequal contest between employers and workers, so there’s no reason to expect them to be fair. Instead, a fair wage can be worked out from what a worker needs to live decently, then fixed by law.
Justice H. B. Higgins made this argument in the 1907 Harvester judgment, which laid the groundwork for Australia’s basic wage. He rejected leaving pay to the unequal contest of the market and based a fair wage instead on “the normal needs of the average employee, regarded as a human being living in a civilised community.”
a fair wage
My dictionary says ‘fair’ means “impartial and just treatment or behavior without favoritism or discrimination”. But trying to legally entrench benefits for employees over their employers is a form of favoritism. It’s clearly taking sides (no less in a battle among pressure groups the government created in the first place) and not impartial at all.
#6141·Dennis HackethalOP, 2 days ago·AI-assistedWages should be set by workers’ needs, not by market bargaining. Left to the market, wages come out of an unequal contest between employers and workers, so there’s no reason to expect them to be fair. Instead, a fair wage can be worked out from what a worker needs to live decently, then fixed by law.
Justice H. B. Higgins made this argument in the 1907 Harvester judgment, which laid the groundwork for Australia’s basic wage. He rejected leaving pay to the unequal contest of the market and based a fair wage instead on “the normal needs of the average employee, regarded as a human being living in a civilised community.”
a fair wage
Paying somebody more than his contributions are worth is actually unfair, in the sense of injustice. See also:

#6141·Dennis HackethalOP, 2 days ago·AI-assistedWages should be set by workers’ needs, not by market bargaining. Left to the market, wages come out of an unequal contest between employers and workers, so there’s no reason to expect them to be fair. Instead, a fair wage can be worked out from what a worker needs to live decently, then fixed by law.
Justice H. B. Higgins made this argument in the 1907 Harvester judgment, which laid the groundwork for Australia’s basic wage. He rejected leaving pay to the unequal contest of the market and based a fair wage instead on “the normal needs of the average employee, regarded as a human being living in a civilised community.”
a fair wage
Higgins is fudging political/legal justice and economic justice.
To find out what one man finds economically fair, you’d have to ask him. He wouldn’t agree to an employment offer he doesn’t find fair. He must find it better than whatever else he can reasonably expect to do with his time, otherwise he wouldn’t voluntarily enter into the contract (see #6123).
Should he later find that the employer tricked him somehow, he can sue. It’s one thing to have laws for that (political justice). It’s another thing entirely to forbid some employment in the first place.
#6149·Dennis HackethalOP, 2 days agoEffective or not, at least the advocates of the minimum wage have good intentions.
Sowell also argues:
If [today’s advocates of the minimum wage] thought things through, how could they have imagined that having large numbers of idle teenage boys hanging out on the streets together would be good for any community — especially in places where most of these youngsters were raised by single mothers, another unintended consequence, in this case, of well-meaning welfare policies?
And, as mentioned in #6148, minimum-wage laws have had “devastating effects … on black teenage unemployment rates” in particular.
So it’s especially contradictory to advocate minimum-wage laws on social-justice grounds.
#6149·Dennis HackethalOP, 2 days agoEffective or not, at least the advocates of the minimum wage have good intentions.
Related to #6151, unions in particular use the minimum wage for evil:
Labor unions have been supporters of minimum-wage laws in countries around the world, since these laws price non-union workers out of jobs, leaving more jobs for union members.
#6149·Dennis HackethalOP, 2 days agoEffective or not, at least the advocates of the minimum wage have good intentions.
No, minimum-wage laws have originally racist motivations in several jurisdictions:
- British Columbia, a minimum-wage law passed in 1925 to price Japanese immigrants out of jobs in lumber.
- Australia, to “‘protect the white Australian’s standard of living from the invidious competition of the colored races, particularly of the Chinese,’ who were willing to work for less.”
- South Africa during apartheid, when “white labor unions urged that a minimum-wage law be applied to all races, to keep black workers from taking jobs away from white unionized workers by working for less than the union pay scale.”
- The United States, with the Davis-Bacon Act of 1931, whose supporters “used exactly the same rationale, citing the fact that Southern construction companies, using non-union black workers, were able to come north and under-bid construction companies using unionized white labor.”
Historically, advocates of the minimum wage understood its effects and used them strategically.
#6149·Dennis HackethalOP, 2 days agoEffective or not, at least the advocates of the minimum wage have good intentions.
One of the great mistakes is to judge policies and programs by their intentions rather than their results. We all know a famous road that is paved with good intentions.
The people who go around talking about their soft heart …, it very often extends to their head as well, because … the programs that are labeled as being for the poor, for the needy, almost always have effects exactly the opposite of those which their well-intentioned sponsors intend them to have.
Effective or not, at least the advocates of the minimum wage have good intentions.
#6141·Dennis HackethalOP, 2 days ago·AI-assistedWages should be set by workers’ needs, not by market bargaining. Left to the market, wages come out of an unequal contest between employers and workers, so there’s no reason to expect them to be fair. Instead, a fair wage can be worked out from what a worker needs to live decently, then fixed by law.
Justice H. B. Higgins made this argument in the 1907 Harvester judgment, which laid the groundwork for Australia’s basic wage. He rejected leaving pay to the unequal contest of the market and based a fair wage instead on “the normal needs of the average employee, regarded as a human being living in a civilised community.”
Economist Thomas Sowell argues that focusing on “needs” or “fair wage[s]” is bad because those criteria “pay[] little or no attention to the worker’s skill level, experience, or general productivity. So it is hardly surprising that minimum-wage laws set wages that price many young workers out of jobs.” He says such laws have had “devastating effects … on black teenage unemployment rates” in particular.
a fair wage can be worked out from what a worker needs to live decently
Bureaucrats can’t know what one man needs. That information doesn’t exist in the aggregate. See Hayek’s ‘The Use of Knowledge in Society’, which I simplified here. Justice Higgins should be more humble and aware of epistemological limitations.
a fair wage can be worked out from what a worker needs to live decently
Bureaucrats can’t know what one man needs. That information doesn’t exist in the aggregate. See Hayek’s ‘The Use of Knowledge in Society’, which I simplified here. Justice Higgins should be more humble and aware of epistemological limitations.
The information Higgins wants is hard to come by. Prices can find and communicate it, fallibly, when not tampered with. Tamper with them, and it gets even harder to find that information.
#6141·Dennis HackethalOP, 2 days ago·AI-assistedWages should be set by workers’ needs, not by market bargaining. Left to the market, wages come out of an unequal contest between employers and workers, so there’s no reason to expect them to be fair. Instead, a fair wage can be worked out from what a worker needs to live decently, then fixed by law.
Justice H. B. Higgins made this argument in the 1907 Harvester judgment, which laid the groundwork for Australia’s basic wage. He rejected leaving pay to the unequal contest of the market and based a fair wage instead on “the normal needs of the average employee, regarded as a human being living in a civilised community.”
civilised community
A civilized community doesn’t use force against peaceable citizens. Minimum wage laws outlaw, at the threat of violence, employment contracts that peaceable citizens would otherwise have entered into voluntarily.
#6141·Dennis HackethalOP, 2 days ago·AI-assistedWages should be set by workers’ needs, not by market bargaining. Left to the market, wages come out of an unequal contest between employers and workers, so there’s no reason to expect them to be fair. Instead, a fair wage can be worked out from what a worker needs to live decently, then fixed by law.
Justice H. B. Higgins made this argument in the 1907 Harvester judgment, which laid the groundwork for Australia’s basic wage. He rejected leaving pay to the unequal contest of the market and based a fair wage instead on “the normal needs of the average employee, regarded as a human being living in a civilised community.”
a fair wage can be worked out from what a worker needs to live decently
Bureaucrats can’t know what one man needs. That information doesn’t exist in the aggregate. See Hayek’s ‘The Use of Knowledge in Society’, which I simplified here. Justice Higgins should be more humble and aware of epistemological limitations.
#6141·Dennis HackethalOP, 2 days ago·AI-assistedWages should be set by workers’ needs, not by market bargaining. Left to the market, wages come out of an unequal contest between employers and workers, so there’s no reason to expect them to be fair. Instead, a fair wage can be worked out from what a worker needs to live decently, then fixed by law.
Justice H. B. Higgins made this argument in the 1907 Harvester judgment, which laid the groundwork for Australia’s basic wage. He rejected leaving pay to the unequal contest of the market and based a fair wage instead on “the normal needs of the average employee, regarded as a human being living in a civilised community.”
unequal contest between employers and workers
This is a mistaken socialist talking point. The idea is that employers have ‘power’ over prospective employees (not ‘workers’) because the latter ‘need’ a job.
But the reality is that employers also need employees. There can be swings from a buyer’s to a seller’s market, yes, but once again (see #6125) regulators should take a look in the mirror to see if they caused any of the conditions that made it harder for people to find jobs that pay well.
Ironically, the minimum wage is itself one such regulation. And it affects industries that are already heavily regulated, such as grocery stores. Existing regulation makes it harder for new competitors to enter the market – who would otherwise have competed not just for customers but also for employees.
#6141·Dennis HackethalOP, 2 days ago·AI-assistedWages should be set by workers’ needs, not by market bargaining. Left to the market, wages come out of an unequal contest between employers and workers, so there’s no reason to expect them to be fair. Instead, a fair wage can be worked out from what a worker needs to live decently, then fixed by law.
Justice H. B. Higgins made this argument in the 1907 Harvester judgment, which laid the groundwork for Australia’s basic wage. He rejected leaving pay to the unequal contest of the market and based a fair wage instead on “the normal needs of the average employee, regarded as a human being living in a civilised community.”
a fair wage can be worked out from what a worker needs to live decently, then fixed by law
Prices can’t be set by decree. The economy, like a person’s mind, is a creative engine, and prices are its feedback mechanism, much as emotions are for the mind. So you can’t fix a wage by decree any more than a person can just ‘decide’ to be happy.
Wages should be set by workers’ needs, not by market bargaining. Left to the market, wages come out of an unequal contest between employers and workers, so there’s no reason to expect them to be fair. Instead, a fair wage can be worked out from what a worker needs to live decently, then fixed by law.
Justice H. B. Higgins made this argument in the 1907 Harvester judgment, which laid the groundwork for Australia’s basic wage. He rejected leaving pay to the unequal contest of the market and based a fair wage instead on “the normal needs of the average employee, regarded as a human being living in a civilised community.”
#6103·Dennis Hackethal, 7 days ago·AI-assistedOEIS A307491 and A307492 Are Complete: A Proof with Oranges and Elliptic Curves
Photo by Jen Gunter on Unsplash
Some numbers of oranges can be laid flat as a triangle with one orange exactly in the middle. Some can be stacked into a neat pyramid. Very few numbers can do both.
So far, people have known five numbers that can: 1, 4, 10, 4960 and 428536. Computers had searched up to numbers with 29 digits without finding a sixth, but nobody knew whether one was hiding further out.
I asked an AI (Anthropic’s Claude) to discover something new, and it produced a proof that there is no sixth number. The five known ones are all there are.
In mathematical terms: the sequence A307491 in the OEIS (the On-Line Encyclopedia of Integer Sequences), “Numbers that are both centered triangular and tetrahedral”, is finite and complete. (‘Tetrahedral’ basically means: having the shape of a pyramid with a triangular base.) The proof finds all lattice points on an elliptic curve, meaning all points whose coordinates are whole numbers. (Mathematicians call these ‘integral points’. The term comes from ‘integer’ and has nothing to do with integrals in calculus.) The same method shows that the sequence for A307492, “Numbers that are both centered square and square pyramidal”, is complete as well: 1, 5, 42925, 1026745.
This article explains the puzzle and then walks through both proofs. They rely on computer algebra software and have not yet been checked by a mathematician, so criticism is welcome. Simply highlight any passage you think is wrong and click ‘Criticize’ in the menu that appears.
The puzzle: which numbers are both centered triangular and tetrahedral?
Take 4 oranges. You can lay them flat – one in the middle, three around it – to make a triangle. Or you can build a little pyramid: three on the bottom, one on top.
Both shapes are drawn from above. The flat shape on the left is a single layer. The pyramid has two layers, with the dark orange sitting on top of the other three.
10 oranges, the next number in the sequence, work too. The flat shape is the bowling-pin triangle, which has one orange in its exact middle. The pyramid has layers of 6, 3, and 1.
In simple terms, the question is: which numbers of oranges can you turn into a flat triangle and then rearrange into a pyramid?
Most numbers fail. Flat centered triangles need 1, 4, 10, 19, 31, 46, … oranges. Pyramids need 1, 4, 10, 20, 35, 56, … oranges. A number only counts if it is on both lists. After 10 the lists drift apart, and the next matches are 4960 (a pyramid 30 layers tall) and 428536 (136 layers tall).
Mathematicians call the first list the centered triangular numbers (A005448) and the second the tetrahedral numbers (A000292). The numbers on both lists form A307491. Its OEIS entry says if a sixth term a(6) exists, it’s larger than 1029.
Why a computer search isn’t enough
A search can only ever say ‘nothing up to here’. Numbers never end, so no search rules out a sixth match. To close the question you need an argument that covers all numbers at once. That argument is the proof.
From figurate numbers to a Diophantine equation
A ‘figurate’ number is a number of dots (or oranges) that can be arranged into a regular geometric shape, like a triangle, square, or pyramid. Tetrahedral and centered triangular numbers are both examples. A Diophantine equation is one where only whole-number solutions count, named after the ancient Greek mathematician Diophantus. We want such an equation because we can’t have a fraction of a layer or ring.
First we need a formula for each shape. A centered triangle has one orange in the middle, and its rings hold 3, 6, 9, … oranges. With k rings, that adds up to
(3k² + 3k + 2)/2
oranges. (For k = 1 this gives 4, and for k = 2 it gives 10.) A pyramid’s layers hold 1, 3, 6, 10, … oranges, counting from the top. With m layers, that adds up to
m(m + 1)(m + 2)/6
oranges. (For m = 2 this gives 4, and for m = 3 it gives 10.) A number can make both shapes exactly when the two formulas give the same value. So the puzzle is a Diophantine equation: find all whole numbers m and k such that
(3k² + 3k + 2)/2 = m(m + 1)(m + 2)/6
The fractions and the mix of k² and k make this equation awkward to work with, so we tidy it up in two moves. First, multiply both sides by 24. (Multiplying by 12 would already clear the fractions, but the extra factor of 2 keeps everything in whole numbers in the next move.) The left side becomes 36k² + 36k + 24 and the right side becomes 4m³ + 12m² + 8m. Second, complete the square on the left: 36k² + 36k + 24 is the same as 9(2k + 1)² + 15. Substituting Y for 2k + 1 and moving the 15 to the other side, the equation turns into
9Y² = 4m³ + 12m² + 8m − 15
A square on one side and a cubic on the other: that’s the signature of an elliptic curve, a type of equation mathematicians have studied for well over a century and have strong tools for. Those tools expect a standard form in which the square and the cube stand alone, without the 9 and the 4 in front. A rescaling achieves that. Multiply both sides by 11664, chosen because 9 × 11664 = 324² and 4 × 11664 = 36³, and set X = 36m, V = 324Y:
V² = X³ + 108X² + 2592X − 174960
Nothing has been lost along the way: every solution of the orange puzzle gives a lattice point on this curve, meaning a point whose coordinates X and V are both whole numbers. The name comes from picturing the whole-number points of the plane as a regular grid, or lattice. So if we can list all lattice points on the curve, we have caught every solution of the puzzle.
The curve V² = X³ + 108X² + 2592X − 174960 near the first three solutions. Two more solutions (4960 and 428536 oranges) lie far off to the right, at X = 1080 and X = 4896.
The chart shows the part of the curve near the first three solutions. Only lattice points matter. Because the equation only involves V², and −V squared is the same as V squared, the full curve also has a mirror image below the horizontal axis, where V is negative. The chart leaves it out because a negative V would mean a negative number of rings, so we have no use for those points.
To see how a point on the chart relates to oranges, take (72, 972). Plugging X = 72 and V = 972 into the equation gives 944784 on both sides, and that is what it means for the point to be on the curve. The number of oranges comes from translating back. Since X = 36m, we get m = 72 ÷ 36 = 2 layers, and a pyramid with 2 layers has 4 oranges. Likewise, since V = 324Y, we get Y = 972 ÷ 324 = 3, and Y = 2k + 1 then gives k = 1 ring, which is also 4 oranges.
The proof: all lattice points on the elliptic curve
Step 1: only finitely many lattice points exist. This is Siegel’s theorem, which Carl Ludwig Siegel proved in his 1929 paper Über einige Anwendungen diophantischer Approximationen. It holds for every elliptic curve. Since our curve is elliptic, the list of solutions must end. But the theorem only says that the list is finite, not what is on it. The work is in finding all of them.
Step 2: determine the rank of the curve. A rational point is one whose coordinates are fractions. Two rational points on an elliptic curve can be combined into a third by a geometric rule: draw the line through them and see where it meets the curve again. Mathematicians call this process ‘adding’ points.1 On our curve, for example, the line through the points for 1 and 4 oranges meets the curve again exactly at the point for 10 oranges, as the chart below shows.2 All rational points can be built this way from a few ‘generator’ points, and the number of generators needed is the curve’s rank (the Mordell–Weil rank). We need the generators because step 3 starts from them. A standard method called 2-descent shows this curve has exactly rank 2. Two independent programs (mwrank and PARI/GP) agree, and mwrank reports the result as certain rather than conditional.
The straight line through the points for 1 and 4 oranges meets the curve again at the point for 10 oranges. At this scale, the dashed line and the curve are almost on top of each other.
The gap between the curve and the line, magnified. The curve crosses the line at exactly the three solutions.
Step 3: find every lattice point. Every lattice point is also a rational point, so it is some combination of the generators. The question is which combinations land on lattice points. There’s a known algorithm for answering it, published in 1994 by Stroeker and Tzanakis and, independently, by Gebel, Pethő, and Zimmer. It uses a theoretical upper bound on how large such a point can be (from the theory of linear forms in elliptic logarithms, which extends Baker’s method to elliptic curves), shrinks that enormous bound with a technique called LLL reduction, and then checks the small remaining range directly. The implementation in SageMath finds exactly 14 lattice points on this curve.
Step 4: translate back to oranges. Not all 14 lattice points correspond to an arrangement of oranges. To get back from a point to layers and rings, we divide: m = X ÷ 36 and Y = V ÷ 324. A point only counts if both divisions come out as whole numbers. For example, (304, 6220) is on the curve, but 304 ÷ 36 is about 8.4, and a pyramid can’t have 8.4 layers. Ten of the 14 points pass. They come in mirror pairs (V and −V), because squaring removes the sign. The points with negative V would mean a negative number of rings, so we drop them like we did above, which leaves five solutions. Recovering k from Y = 2k + 1, these are
Number of oranges k (rings) m (pyramid layers) 1 0 1 4 1 2 10 2 3 4960 57 30 428536 534 136 Those are the five known numbers. Since every solution of the puzzle must appear among the 14 points, there is no sixth. A307491 is finite and complete.
Second result: OEIS A307492 (centered square and square pyramidal) is complete, too
Now let’s replace triangles with squares. Take 5 oranges. You can lay them flat as a square with one in the middle. Or you can build a square pyramid: four on the bottom, one on top.
Which numbers are both a centered square number, 2k² + 2k + 1, and a square pyramidal number, m(m + 1)(2m + 1)/6? The same steps work. Setting the two formulas equal, multiplying by 12 and completing the square with Y = 2k + 1 gives 6Y² = 4m³ + 6m² + 2m − 6. Rescaling with X = 24m, V = 144Y then gives the elliptic curve
V² = X³ + 36X² + 288X − 20736
It also has rank 2 and 14 lattice points. Filtering them as in step 4 leaves these solutions:
Number of oranges k (rings) m (pyramid layers) 1 0 1 5 1 2 42925 146 50 1026745 716 145 So A307492 is complete: 1, 5, 42925, 1026745. Its OEIS entry had the same open ‘greater than 1029’ comment.
Reproduce it yourself
You don’t have to take the software steps on faith. Anyone can re-run them in SageMath, which is free. The following lines define the first curve (the one for flat triangles and triangular pyramids, A307491), compute its rank, and list its lattice points. The numbers in the first line are the coefficients of the curve’s equation.
pythonE = EllipticCurve([0, 108, 0, 2592, -174960])C = E.mwrank_curve()print(C.rank(), C.certain())# 2 Trueprint(E.integral_points(both_signs=True))# [(36 : -324 : 1), (36 : 324 : 1), (72 : -972 : 1), (72 : 972 : 1),# (108 : -1620 : 1), (108 : 1620 : 1), (304 : -6220 : 1), (304 : 6220 : 1),# (477 : -11583 : 1), (477 : 11583 : 1), (1080 : -37260 : 1), (1080 : 37260 : 1),# (4896 : -346356 : 1), (4896 : 346356 : 1)]With SageMath 10.8, the first line of output is “2 True”, meaning rank 2, proven. The second line lists the 14 lattice points. SageMath writes each one in the form
(X : V : 1). In ordinary notation, they are(36, ±324), (72, ±972), (108, ±1620), (304, ±6220), (477, ±11583), (1080, ±37260)and(4896, ±346356). Checking that a given point lies on the curve only takes a calculator. The software is needed to be sure that there are no others.For the second curve (the one for flat squares and square pyramids, A307492), replace the list in the first line with
[0, 36, 0, 288, -20736]. The output is again “2 True”, and the 14 lattice points are(24, ±144), (36, ±288), (48, ±432), (85, ±937), (468, ±10512), (1200, ±42192)and(3480, ±206352).A related search: the same number in several dimensions
A flat triangle and a pyramid belong to one family. There are also ‘triangles’ in four, five and more dimensions, and counting their oranges gives the numbers in Pascal’s triangle. That raises a similar question: which numbers show up in Pascal’s triangle in several different places? Its mirror symmetry makes most numbers show up at least twice. Showing up more often than that is rare: apart from one infinite family, only a few such numbers are known, such as 120 and 3003. How often a number can repeat like this is a famous open problem called Singmaster’s conjecture.
A 2017 paper by Blokhuis, Brouwer and de Weger lists the known repeats, checked up to 1060. It also lists the known pairs of such numbers that differ by exactly 1, like 252 and 253, checked up to 1030. Claude extended both checks to 1070 and found nothing new. Unlike the two results above, this is a search and not a proof, so it says nothing about numbers beyond 1070.
How much to trust these findings
- The whole thing was produced by my AI, not by me, and no mathematician has reviewed it yet. The advent of competent AI calls for some new etiquette so unqualified people like me can report potential discoveries to experts without wasting their time. I’m not aware of any such etiquette, so I decided to blog about the potential discovery first. As a result, I had to strike a balance between making the article accessible to a general audience while also speaking to mathematicians. Anyone with SageMath or Magma can recompute the lattice points of the two curves above in seconds (those programs call them ‘integral points’).
- As shown above, these proofs are computer-assisted. Steps 2 and 3 are standard, widely used algorithms, but I’m trusting their implementations.
- I’m not a mathematician. I was good at undergrad computer-science and business-school math but didn’t go beyond that. And that was a while ago. That said, I kept asking my AI questions about the math until I understood it, and I ran the SageMath script to reproduce the results. AI wrote this article but I heavily edited it.
- As a further check, my AI ran the same code on two related puzzles whose complete answers are already in the literature: square tetrahedral numbers (A003556) and numbers both triangular and square pyramidal (A039596). It reproduced both lists exactly.
- My AI searched for an earlier proof and found none, but I can’t rule out that one exists somewhere. (For what it’s worth, both OEIS entries are still open at the time of writing, and web and arXiv searches on both sequences’ terms together with ‘elliptic curve’ turned up no proofs.)
Strictly speaking, the ‘sum’ of two points is the mirror image of that third point across the horizontal axis: same X, opposite V. The mirror image of a lattice point is again a lattice point, so this detail doesn’t affect the argument. ↑
That whole-number result is an exception. Usually the new point has fractions as coordinates. For example, combining the 4-orange point with itself (using the line that just touches the curve there) leads to a point with X = 436/9. This is why lattice points are so rare. ↑
A smaller result from the same prompt (‘discover something nobody has discovered before’), again produced by Claude and not yet checked by a mathematician:
Claim: OEIS A281710 equals F(n+1) + 9 for all n ≥ 4, where F is the Fibonacci sequence (F(1) = F(2) = 1).
A281710 counts the n×3 arrays of 0s and 1s in which no cell differs from a strict majority of its horizontal, diagonal and antidiagonal neighbors, with the top-left cell fixed at 0. Its OEIS entry lists the recurrence a(n) = 2a(n−1) − a(n−3) for n > 6 and a generating function, both marked ‘Empirical’, meaning they were guessed from the data. The claim above implies both, so it would turn them into theorems.
Proof sketch:
- Whether a row is valid depends only on the rows directly above and below it. So the arrays can be counted with a transfer matrix whose states are pairs of adjacent rows. There are at most 64 such pairs. By the Cayley–Hamilton theorem, a(n) therefore satisfies a linear recurrence of order at most 64 for n ≥ 2.
- F(n+1) + 9 satisfies a linear recurrence of order 3.
- So the difference a(n) − F(n+1) − 9 satisfies a linear recurrence of order at most 67. A sequence like that is zero forever once it is zero for 67 terms in a row.
- Computing a(n) with the transfer matrix shows the difference is zero for every n from 4 to 300, which is 297 terms in a row.
Checks: a brute-force count over all arrays for n ≤ 6 agrees with the transfer matrix, and the computed terms match the terms listed in the OEIS entry.
Caveats: as of November 12, 2026, the OEIS entry shows no proof and doesn’t mention Fibonacci, but the wider literature was not searched, so an earlier proof may exist. Criticism is welcome.
#6131·Zelalem Mekonnen, 5 days agoArtists can focus on making art early on when they are starting out.
Imagine a singer in Nashville that is just starting out. If they are able to find a minimum wage that is decent enough for them not to think about having a good place to live and having good meals, they can instead focus on making music.
having a good place to live and having good meals
The employer hires someone not for charity but because of the value they bring. That value isn’t suddenly increased by making hiring them more expensive.
#6131·Zelalem Mekonnen, 5 days agoArtists can focus on making art early on when they are starting out.
Imagine a singer in Nashville that is just starting out. If they are able to find a minimum wage that is decent enough for them not to think about having a good place to live and having good meals, they can instead focus on making music.
having a good place to live and having good meals
Those goals are actually more attainable without minimum-wage laws. That’s because minimum wage laws, like most regulations, make it harder to create common preferences (and thus wealth). See #6133.
#6131·Zelalem Mekonnen, 5 days agoArtists can focus on making art early on when they are starting out.
Imagine a singer in Nashville that is just starting out. If they are able to find a minimum wage that is decent enough for them not to think about having a good place to live and having good meals, they can instead focus on making music.
Those artists should get a job that pays more on its own, not get the government to force employers to pay them more. Otherwise one might as well argue that the government should force employers to pay employees a trillion dollars for one minute of work so they never have to worry about money again…
Nobody who works full time should be poor
Why shouldn’t someone who works full time be poor? This idea assumes that working full time entitles a person to a certain income, but on what grounds? I could work full time doing something nobody wants to pay me for. Why would the hours I put in entitle me to pay above a government-set floor?
Nobody who works full time should be poor
Why should someone who works full time automatically not be poor? This idea assumes that working full time entitles a person to a certain income, but on what grounds? I could work full time doing something nobody wants to pay me for. Why would the hours I put in entitle me to pay above a government-set floor?
Emphasize that common preferences are created not merely found
the minimum wage should be raised.
You can’t make someone richer by upping a number on a piece of paper. It’s a naive and mystical idea. The only legitimate way people get richer is by finding common preferences. That takes creativity, not the mechanical raising of numbers by fait/law. You can’t outlaw poverty. If you want people to get richer, reduce regulatory hurdles to make it easier for them to find common preferences.
the minimum wage should be raised.
You can’t make someone richer by upping a number on a piece of paper. It’s a naive and mystical idea. The only legitimate way people get richer is by creating common preferences. That takes creativity, not the mechanical raising of numbers by fait/law. You can’t outlaw poverty. If you want people to get richer, reduce regulatory hurdles to make it easier for them to create common preferences.
#6126·Dennis HackethalOP, 5 days ago·AI-assistedThe government should protect the poor. The rich can look after themselves, but the poor have nothing to fall back on and must depend on the state. Since most wage earners are poor, the government should protect them, including by making sure their wages are enough to live on.
Pope Leo XIII made this argument in his 1891 encyclical Rerum Novarum. He wrote that wage-earners “should be specially cared for and protected by the government” (§37), and that wages “ought not to be insufficient to support a frugal and well-behaved wage-earner” (§45).
the government should protect them
Artists can focus on making art early on when they are starting out.
Imagine a singer in Nashville that is just starting out. If they are able to find a minimum wage that is decent enough for them not to think about having a good place to live and having good meals, they can instead focus on making music.
#6126·Dennis HackethalOP, 5 days ago·AI-assistedThe government should protect the poor. The rich can look after themselves, but the poor have nothing to fall back on and must depend on the state. Since most wage earners are poor, the government should protect them, including by making sure their wages are enough to live on.
Pope Leo XIII made this argument in his 1891 encyclical Rerum Novarum. He wrote that wage-earners “should be specially cared for and protected by the government” (§37), and that wages “ought not to be insufficient to support a frugal and well-behaved wage-earner” (§45).
Since most wage earners are poor, the government should protect them, including by making sure their wages are enough to live on.
If I would like to work some job for $10/hour, but the state says I can’t accept the job for less than $11, at which rate it is not being offered, then the state is dooming me to be unemployed. It’s become my destroyer, not my protector.








