BountiesBeta

Criticism Pays

People put up money for criticism of ideas, their own or anyone’s. Show what’s wrong with one, and if your criticism holds up, you get paid.

Offered so far
USD 5,430.00
Bounties
10
Criticisms submitted
19

How It Works

  1. Someone puts up money

    They pick an idea, say what criticism they’ll pay for, and fund the bounty. Others can add to it.

  2. You criticize the idea

    Submit a direct criticism that meets the terms. You need the Beginner, Engager, and Defender badges to take part.

  3. Get paid for criticism that holds up

    If the owner doesn’t reject it and it has no pending criticisms by the deadline, you get paid through Stripe.

Active Bounties

StandingAccepting submissions
USD 500.00

USD 250.00 for the next eligible criticism

Our ideas can be 100% true in the sense of absolute truth. It’s possible to come up with true ideas. There’s no criterion of truth to tell that they’re true, but they can still be true.

By Dennis Hackethal1 submission
StandingAccepting submissions
USD 150.00

USD 50.00 for the next eligible criticism

autopair.js is bug-free.

By Dennis Hackethal0 submissions
StandingAccepting submissions
USD 150.00

USD 50.00 for the next eligible criticism

Hiccdown is bug-free.

By Dennis Hackethal0 submissions

Past Bounties

Closed early
USD 30.00

Closed early, with no eligible submissions

Whether the above idea (#4751) is refuted or not, there are no viable alternative solutions to the "PROBLEM" raised in #4752. (Criticize this with alternative solutions).

By Tyler Mills0 submissions
Awarded
USD 50.00

Awarded to Knut Sondre Sæbø

By this standard, a random number generator has universal creativity as well, and is therefore a person. So there must be a standard for personhood other than: able to generate any possible explanation. Such as: can do that tractably.

By Tyler Mills5 submissions
Closed
USD 3,600.00

Finished about 1 month ago

My critique of David Deutsch’s The Beginning of Infinity as a programmer. In short, his ‘hard to vary’ criterion at the core of his epistemology is fatally underspecified and impossible to apply. Deutsch says that one should adopt…

By Dennis Hackethal5 submissions
Closed early
USD 250.00

Closed early, with no eligible submissions

Focus is usually defined in coercive terms—working without distraction or despite it. This framing sneaks discipline in through the side door. Deep Work: Focus is the ability to concentrate on cognitively demanding tasks without…

By Edwin de Wit0 submissions
Awarded
USD 100.00

Awarded to Zakery Mizell

Option 1: Continue working the day job and balancing the other pursuits on the side.

By Dennis Hackethal2 submissions
Closed early
USD 100.00

Closed early, with no eligible submissions

Option 2: Go on hiatus from the day job/career, and focus on creative pursuits and research, full-time, for some number of months (duration perhaps depending on job opportunities).

By Tyler Mills3 submissions
Closed early
USD 500.00

Closed early, with no eligible submissions

My critique of David Deutsch’s The Beginning of Infinity as a programmer. In short, his ‘hard to vary’ criterion at the core of his epistemology is fatally underspecified and impossible to apply. Deutsch says that one should adopt…

By Dennis Hackethal3 submissions

Want an Idea Criticized?

Start a bounty on any idea, yours or anyone’s, from the menu next to it. Starting one takes the Beginner and Defender badges.

Find an idea