Why Don’t We Feel the Earth Move?

Showing only #5792 and its comments.

See chronicle
Discussions can branch out indefinitely. You may need to scroll sideways.
The discussion as it was in 1588. Chronicle discussions are read-only. Jump to the present
Claudius Ptolemy’s avatar
Claudius PtolemyHistorical profile​·​#5792​·​about 150 CE​·​AI-assisted
1st of 2 versions​·​latest

The Earth stands still at the center of the universe. The Moon, the Sun, and the planets circle it.

Criticized1
Nicolaus Copernicus’s avatar
Nicolaus CopernicusHistorical profile​·​#5801​·​1543​·​AI-assisted

Ptolemy’s system has to set by hand that Mercury and Venus never stray far from the Sun, and that the outer planets loop backward just when they’re opposite the Sun in the sky. It never explains why. If the Earth and the planets all circle the Sun, both follow.

Criticism of #5792
Claudius Ptolemy’s avatar
Claudius PtolemyHistorical profile​·​#5793​·​about 150 CE​·​AI-assisted

Every so often, a planet seems to stop, drift backward among the stars for weeks, and then move on. A planet that simply circled the Earth would never do that.

Criticism of #5792Criticized1
Claudius Ptolemy’s avatar
Claudius PtolemyHistorical profile​·​#5794​·​about 150 CE​·​AI-assisted

Each planet rides on a small circle, an epicycle, whose center travels along a larger one around the Earth. On the near side of its epicycle, the planet moves against the larger circle’s motion, so it seems to drift backward.

Criticism of #5793
  • Rationally adoptable.
  • Not rationally adoptable.
  • Older versions with pending criticisms.
  • Ideas are blue, criticisms red, comments small and gray.
  • Hover over ideas to expand them.
  • Click on ideas to jump to their place in the discussion.