Search

Words match in any order. "many worlds" matches the phrase exactly; -gravity excludes ideas with “gravity”.

Ideas that are…

Search Ideas


914 ideas match your query.:

Superseded by #2501.

#2502·​Dennis HackethalOP, about 1 year ago·​CriticismArchived

Since I am getting an error when I try to edit #2479, I will make a new criticism. I think #2479 is unclear.

I would have it that each criticism and counter-criticism resets the countdown on the bounty deadline. This means everyone involved is given fair time to respond at each turn.

A small downside is that a bounty can go on indefinitely, but that is simply an extension of the fact that solutions to problems don’t come reliably.

#2501·​Benjamin Davies, about 1 year ago·​Criticism1 pending criticismArchived

The counter-criticism moves the deadline forward again the same fixed amount.

#2479·​Benjamin Davies, about 1 year ago·​Criticism1 pending criticismArchived

I suppose that would make it a bit harder for bad actors because they’d need to monitor multiple deadlines, but they could still submit arbitrary counter-criticisms just in time to avoid paying. Or is there something I’m missing?

#2478·​Dennis HackethalOP, about 1 year ago·​Criticism1 pending criticismArchived

I think definitely worth trying, sounds like fun

#2477·​Benjamin Davies, about 1 year ago

The timeframe to address the criticism should start counting down from the moment the criticism is made, rather than the original post. So it would be a continuous thing rather than a single deadline for everyone.

The OP could end the bounty if there are no outstanding criticisms and he no longer seeks a solution.

#2476·​Benjamin Davies, about 1 year ago·​Criticism1 pending criticismArchived

Yes, that was what I was thinking. Presumably the OP could set their own deadline timeframe too.

#2475·​Benjamin Davies, about 1 year ago·​Archived

As much as I dislike LLMs, I’m thinking of using them to show summaries of discussions at the top of the page. Summaries would reflect ideas without pending criticisms.

#2473·​Dennis HackethalOP, about 1 year ago

But then bad actors could always submit arbitrary counter-criticisms just before the deadline to avoid paying.

#2472·​Dennis HackethalOP, about 1 year ago·​Criticism1 pending criticismArchived

I’m not sure yet, but I’m playing with the idea that the criticism can’t have any pending counter-criticisms by some deadline.

#2471·​Dennis HackethalOP, about 1 year ago·​Criticism1 pending criticismArchived

Nevermind, this was addressed by #2462

#2469·​Benjamin Davies, about 1 year ago·​CriticismArchived

Why should reacts persist through revisions?

#2468·​Benjamin Davies, about 1 year ago·​Criticism1 pending criticismArchived

How do you ensure the criticism is worthy of the bounty?

#2467·​Benjamin Davies, about 1 year ago·​Criticism1 pending criticismArchived

Not if I do reactions on a per-paragraph basis. I think that’s a new feature none of those sites have.

#2466·​Dennis HackethalOP, about 1 year ago·​Criticism1 pending criticismArchived

The way I picture it, as you hover over different paragraphs, a reaction button appears and moves between paragraphs. So it would always be clear that reactions are on specific paragraphs. The user would pick whatever paragraph they most wish to react to.

#2465·​Dennis HackethalOP, about 1 year ago·​Criticism1 pending criticismArchived

Then what does somebody do who wants to react to an idea as a whole? Do they react to the last paragraph?

#2464·​Dennis HackethalOP, about 1 year ago·​CriticismArchived

For reactions to paragraphs, at least you could tell if the content someone reacted to has changed, and only then remove the reaction.

#2463·​Dennis HackethalOP, about 1 year ago·​CriticismArchived

But presumably, the same is true for reactions to ideas as a whole. Reactions would have to be removed for revisions.

#2462·​Dennis HackethalOP, about 1 year ago·​CriticismArchived

It isn’t clear what would happen during a revision. A paragraph might be changed or deleted. Too complicated.

#2461·​Dennis HackethalOP, about 1 year ago·​Criticism2 pending criticismsArchived

Feature idea: pay people to criticize your idea.

You submit an idea with a ‘criticism bounty’ of ten bucks per criticism received, say.

The amount should be arbitrarily customizable.

#2459·​Dennis HackethalOP revised about 1 year ago·​Original #2442·​Criticism1 pending criticismArchived

I could implement reactions on a per-paragraph basis.

#2458·​Dennis HackethalOP, about 1 year ago·​Criticism2 pending criticismsArchived

There’s value in others being able to react as well. Maybe an idea affects them in some way or they want to voice support.

#2457·​Dennis HackethalOP, about 1 year ago·​CriticismArchived

There’s value in reacting to top-level ideas, too.

#2456·​Dennis HackethalOP, about 1 year ago·​CriticismArchived

Fixed as of recently. Emails now quote the parent idea.

#2443·​Dennis HackethalOP, about 1 year ago·​CriticismArchived

Feature idea: pay people to criticize your idea.

You submit an idea with a ‘criticism bounty’ of ten bucks per criticism received, say.

#2442·​Dennis HackethalOP, about 1 year ago·​Criticism1 pending criticismArchived