Search

Words match in any order. "many worlds" matches the phrase exactly; -gravity excludes ideas with “gravity”.

Ideas that are…

Search Ideas


914 ideas match your query.:

I notice that when I amend a criticism I have made, I’m not able to see what I am criticising. It would be good if the edit screen showed the comment I am disagreeing with similar to how it does when I first go to write a criticism.

#2430·​Benjamin Davies revised about 1 year ago·​Original #2429·​Criticism1 pending criticismArchived

I notice that when I amend a criticism I have made, I’m not able to see what I am criticising. It would be good if the edit screen showed the comment I am disagreeing with similar to how it does when I first go to write a criticism.

#2429·​Benjamin Davies, about 1 year ago·​1 pending criticismArchived

Veritula cautions against making multiple points at once so as to avoid ‘bulk criticism’. But people can write as much as they want in a single idea. For example, you can find several long-form articles in ‘How Does Veritula Work?’. It just depends on how confident people are in their ideas, and how much they have practiced using Veritula.

#2357·​Dennis HackethalOP, about 1 year ago·​Criticism

I would also consider financially supporting someone who gave me good reason to think they had the vision, the motivation, and the technical skill to create it.

I’m interested. Let’s continue this discussion privately for now. Email me: dh at dennishackethal.com

#2356·​Dennis HackethalOP, about 1 year ago

No, I think the ‘Popperian Wikipedia’ idea is too different to Veritula for it to be a competitor. Veritula is primarily a discussion tool. I envision more of an encyclopedia of competing ideas presented independently of each other, with no (or very little) discussion functionality.

For example, on the topic of addiction, this site would contain different articles explaining different models of what addiction is, how it works, etc. Each article would explain the given model from within its own framework, rather than from some pre-approved framework and set of sources (as is currently the case at Wikipedia).

I realise “methods of criticism” in my reply above may have confused that somewhat.

I think my idea could be made within Veritula, if you would be interested. Different explanations could be cataloged in Wikipedia-style articles (with versioning), which could then be referred to and discussed in threads here. Maybe we should open a discussion for this potential feature?

At the end of the day, I think something like that should exist in the world, and I am indifferent to how it might come about. It wouldn’t bother me if I wasn’t involved. I would also consider financially supporting someone who gave me good reason to think they had the vision, the motivation, and the technical skill to create it.

#2353·​Benjamin Davies revised about 1 year ago·​Original #2350

No, I think the ‘Popperian Wikipedia’ idea is too different to Veritula for it to be a competitor. Veritula is primarily a discussion tool. I envision more of an encyclopedia of competing ideas presented independently of each other, with no (or very little) discussion functionality.

For example, on the topic of addiction, this site would contain different articles explaining different models of what addiction is, how it works, etc. Each article would explain the given model from within its own framework, rather than from some pre-approved framework and set of sources (as is currently the case at Wikipedia).

I realise “methods of criticism” in my reply above may have confused that somewhat.

I think my idea could be made within Veritula, if you would be interested. Different explanations could be cataloged in Wikipedia-style articles (with versioning), which could then be referred to and discussed in threads here.

At the end of the day, I think something like that should exist in the world, and I am indifferent to how it might come about. It wouldn’t bother me if I wasn’t involved. I would also consider financially supporting someone who gave me good reason to think they had the vision, the motivation, and the technical skill to create it.

#2351·​Benjamin Davies revised about 1 year ago·​Original #2350·​1 pending criticism

No, I think the ‘Popperian Wikipedia’ idea is too different to Veritula for it to be a competitor. Veritula is primarily a discussion tool. I envision more of an encyclopedia of competing ideas presented independently of each other, with no (or very little) discussion functionality.

For example, on the topic of addiction, this site would contain different articles explaining different models of what addiction is, how it works, etc. Each article would explain the given model from within its own framework, rather than from some pre-approved framework and set of sources (as is currently the case at Wikipedia).

I realise “methods of criticism” in my reply above may have confused that somewhat.

I think my idea could be made within Veritula, if you would be interested. Different explanations could be cataloged in Wikipedia-style articles (with versioning), which could then be referred to and discussed in threads here.

At the end of that day, I think something like that should exist in the world, and I am indifferent to how it might come about. It wouldn’t bother me if I wasn’t involved. I would also consider financially supporting someone who gave me good reason to think they had the vision, the motivation, and the technical skill to create it.

#2350·​Benjamin Davies, about 1 year ago·​1 pending criticism

I’m happy to have you and for your contributions, but I have to ask: do you see yourself building a Veritula competitor at some point in the future?

#2333·​Dennis HackethalOP, about 1 year ago

I’m curious btw, how did you hear about Veritula?

I believe I came across it while exploring your blog. My ‘Popperian Wikipedia’ idea was particularly sharp in my mind in that moment, so I was very excited to see how you had set things up here. I think a tremendous amount of it is transferable.

#2315·​Benjamin Davies, about 1 year ago

My vision is for an online encyclopedia that contains complete articles describing the totality of a perspective, with articles for alternate explanations readily available. I see many problems with this idea but I think it is worth exploring.

#2314·​Benjamin Davies, about 1 year ago

Me, too. I think Veritula’s design allows for this pretty naturally since the topic of a discussion can be general enough for various competing ideas to be posted in the discussion.

Veritula emphasises making one point at a time for ease of criticism and discussion, which is useful in a forum but makes absorbing the totality of an idea a little more tedious compared to a quick glance at an encyclopedia article. (It is possible I have misunderstood some aspect of Veritula here.)

#2313·​Benjamin Davies, about 1 year ago·​Criticism1 pending criticism

Me, too. I think Veritula’s design allows for this pretty naturally since the topic of a discussion can be general enough for various competing ideas to be posted in the discussion.

One thing that Wikipedia articles are very good for is providing well-structured information on a given subject. Discussion threads are not so well structured (the order of information is not based on how high-level or foundational it is, like an encyclopedia entry would be, but rather on the nested chronology of whatever discussion happened to take place.)

#2312·​Benjamin Davies, about 1 year ago·​Criticism1 pending criticism

Would it be possible / worth it to produce a competitor to Wikipedia based on Popperian epistemology?

Yes, sure.

The idea of having a Wikipedia equivalent that presents high quality competing articles detailing different alternative explanations for things (with some sort of versioning and methods of criticism) excites me greatly.

Me, too. I think Veritula’s design allows for this pretty naturally since the topic of a discussion can be general enough for various competing ideas to be posted in the discussion.

We ‘just’ need to get more users. As I wrote in #628, posting a breaking news story could work. If users submit ideas on events as they unfold and then criticize those ideas, visitors see what’s happening at a glance. It could be easier for them to know which ideas they can adopt than on conventional news channels or even Wikipedia, IMO.

There are also ‘timeless’ debates that have been going on for decades where Veritula can offer clarity. Like on the abortion debate. People shouldn’t have to keep debating that over and over when it’s a matter where objective truth can be found and then acted on.

I have thought of producing something like this myself, which was part of what drew me to Veritula.

I’m curious btw, how did you hear about Veritula?

#2311·​Dennis HackethalOP, about 1 year ago

I went ahead and implemented this feature since it was a good suggestion.

You can edit your discussion here.

#2306·​Dennis HackethalOP, about 1 year ago·​1 pending criticismArchived

I started a discussion earlier, and what I wrote in the “about” section of the discussion was not written well. I would like to revise it. Is this possible? If not, is there an intention to make this possible eventually?

#2305·​Benjamin Davies, about 1 year ago·​2 pending criticismsArchived

Would it be possible / worth it to produce a competitor to Wikipedia based on Popperian epistemology? Larry Sanger (a founder of Wikipedia) has said that he now thinks Wikipedia should have competing articles on the same topic to allow for the fact that people disagree.

The idea of having a Wikipedia equivalent that presents high quality competing articles detailing different alternative explanations for things (with some sort of versioning and methods of criticism) excites me greatly.

I have thought of producing something like this myself, which was part of what drew me to Veritula.

#2304·​Benjamin Davies, about 1 year ago

Hardly anyone reads those, and many of those who do forget.

#2244·​Dennis HackethalOP, about 1 year ago·​CriticismArchived

There could be an explanation somewhere stating that emoji reactions do not have epistemological relevance.

#2243·​Dennis HackethalOP, about 1 year ago·​Criticism1 pending criticismArchived

Those run the risk of turning Veritula into yet another social network like Reddit or messenger like Telegram.

#2242·​Dennis HackethalOP, about 1 year ago·​Criticism1 pending criticismArchived

Not necessarily. Maybe somebody just forgot to reply or doesn’t know what to say.

#2188·​Dennis HackethalOP revised about 1 year ago·​Original #2158·​CriticismArchived

Veritula should have some way to indicate agreement; some way to indicate that a particular thread of a discussion is resolved, at least for the time being.

#2169·​Dennis HackethalOP revised about 1 year ago·​Original #2156·​Criticism1 pending criticismArchived

But not everyone will always use the platform in an ideal way, and I don’t want to make it easier for issues to compound.

#2168·​Dennis HackethalOP, about 1 year ago·​CriticismArchived

That only happens if people submit bulk ideas, and people shouldn’t do that anyway.

#2167·​Dennis HackethalOP, about 1 year ago·​Criticism1 pending criticismArchived

Reactions can be ambiguous. It wouldn’t always be clear which part of an idea someone is reacting to.

#2166·​Dennis HackethalOP, about 1 year ago·​Criticism1 pending criticismArchived

That limits the scope of the problem but doesn’t eliminate it. A single recipient could still react in a distracting way.

#2165·​Dennis HackethalOP, about 1 year ago·​CriticismArchived