Search

Ideas that are…

Search Ideas


133 ideas match your query.:

Copyright is stifling to creativity, as now people are not incentivised to write fan-fictions.

#1329·Dennis Hackethal revised 11 months ago·Original #1323·CriticismCriticized3

This idea isn’t marked as a criticism but presumably should be. (Though it need not be marked as a criticism anymore if it’s going to split up into multiple separate submissions as per #1324.)

#1327·Dennis Hackethal revised 11 months ago·Original #1325·Criticism

Copyright is stifling to creativity, as now people are not incentivised to write fan-fictions.

#1326·Dirk MeulenbeltOP revised 11 months ago·Original #1323·Criticized2

This isn’t marked as a criticism but presumably should be. (Though it need not be marked as a criticism anymore if it’s going to be followed up by multiple separate submissions as per #1324.)

#1325·Dennis Hackethal, 11 months ago·CriticismCriticized1

This idea contains at least two claims and one question:

  1. Copyright stifles creativity.
  2. Fan fiction does not damage creators.
  3. “Where is copyright good?”

It’s unwise to submit multiple ideas at once as they each become susceptible to ‘bulk criticism’. That can unduly weaken your own position.

Try submitting the ideas again, separately.

#1324·Dennis Hackethal, 11 months ago·Criticism

This is stifling to creativity, as now people are not incentivised to write fan-fictions as much as without copyright.

I fail to see how fan fiction is at all damaging to an original creator.

We have found an example where copyright is bad.

Where is copyright good?

#1323·Dirk MeulenbeltOP, 11 months ago·Criticized2

Not a lawyer but I believe such fan fiction would be considered a derivative work.

Copyright protects original creators’ exclusive right to create derivative works. So, selling your Star Wars fan fiction without permission from the copyright holders would be copyright infringement.

See this article.

#1322·Dennis Hackethal, 11 months ago

I am not allowed to sell my Star Wars fan-fiction. Why not?

#1321·Dirk MeulenbeltOP, 11 months ago