Search

Words match in any order. "many worlds" matches the phrase exactly; -gravity excludes ideas with “gravity”.

Ideas that are…

Search Ideas


128 ideas match your query.:

If I understand Veritula correctly, we first start with an idea. We accept the idea as true until it has received a criticism. In which case, until the current criticism isn't resolved, the idea is tentatively seen as false and makes no sense to live in accordance to it. We don't submit bulk ideas or criticisms. Ideas (including criticisms), even if they are related should generally be submitted separately. Also, avoid duplicate ideas.

#1874·​Zelalem Mekonnen revised about 1 year ago·​Original #1833·​1 pending criticism

If I understand Veritula correctly, we first start with an idea. We accept the idea as true until it has received a criticism. In which case, until the current criticism isn't resolved, the idea is tentatively seen as false and makes no sense to live in accordance to it. We don't submit bulk ideas or criticisms. Each idea and criticism, even if they are related must be their its own. Also, avoid duplicate ideas.

#1871·​Zelalem Mekonnen revised about 1 year ago·​Original #1833·​2 pending criticisms

What if the point an author is trying to make takes multiple ideas? Say we are talking about comic books and I say "DC comics are better than Marvel, because Thor is a better character than Superman, even thou Batman might be a better character than Iron man?"

#1864·​Zelalem Mekonnen, about 1 year ago

If I understand Veritula correctly, we first start with an idea/conjecture. We accept the idea as true until it has received a criticism. In which case, until the current criticism isn't resolved, the idea is tentatively seen as false and makes no sense to live in accordance to it. We don't do bulk criticism. Each criticism, even if they are related must be in its own. Also, avoid duplicate ideas.

#1858·​Zelalem Mekonnen revised about 1 year ago·​Original #1833·​3 pending criticisms

The gap between "it's" and "its" is big. My lack of paying attention to detail is becoming more and more obvious. In any case.

#1857·​Zelalem Mekonnen, about 1 year ago

Ah. Now I get it!

#1855·​Zelalem Mekonnen, about 1 year ago

If I understand Veritula correctly, we first start with an idea/conjecture. We accept the idea as true until it has received a criticism. In which case, until the current criticism isn't resolved, the idea is tentatively seen as false and makes no sense to live in accordance to it. We don't do bulk criticism. Each criticism, even if they are related must be in it's own. Also, avoid duplicate ideas.

#1854·​Zelalem Mekonnen revised about 1 year ago·​Original #1833·​1 pending criticism

If I understand Veritula correctly, we first start with an idea/conjecture. We accept the idea as true until it has received a criticism. In which case, until the current criticism isn't resolved, the idea is tentatively seen as false and makes no sense to live in accordance to it. We don't do bulk criticism. Each criticism, even if they are related must be in it's own. Also, avoid duplicate ideas.

#1851·​Zelalem Mekonnen revised about 1 year ago·​Original #1833·​2 pending criticisms

What of for "Supersedes previous version?" box? Would that be selected, since the new version would supersede the current version.

#1849·​Zelalem Mekonnen, about 1 year ago

Could you expand more on what you mean by the above question?

#1835·​Zelalem MekonnenOP, about 1 year ago

Ayn Rand claims that "[t]he virtue of Rationality means the recognition and acceptance of reason as one's only source of knowledge [...]." This is wrong, mainly because reason can only be used as a method of choosing between knowledge/ideas, not as the only source of knowledge.

#1834·​Zelalem MekonnenOP revised about 1 year ago·​Original #1616

If I understand Veritula correctly, we first start with an idea/conjecture. We accept the idea as true until it has received a criticism. In which case, until the current criticism isn't resolved, the idea is tentatively seen as false and makes no sense to live in accordance to it. We don't do bulk criticism. Each criticism, even if they are related must be in it's own. Also, avoid duplicate criticism.

#1833·​Zelalem Mekonnen, about 1 year ago·​2 pending criticisms

Say someone said "I had a dream that {insert something true}" or "god told me that {insert something true}," what is the source of knowledge here?

#1820·​Zelalem MekonnenOP, about 1 year ago·​1 pending criticism

This has to take time into context. At one point, a belief in god was all that we had. We didn't have hard to vary explanations. As such, a person might have a belief in god as the only worldview currently. So it isn't irrational for that person, or people back in the days, to believe in god.

#1819·​Zelalem MekonnenOP, about 1 year ago·​Criticism1 pending criticism

Dreams can be a source of knowledge. But dreams aren't always reasonable. Sometimes, dreams are lies.

In that statement, I am looking at reason as a mode of criticism. You might get ideas and potentially knowledge from all sources and reason tests weather they are right or not.

And if I understand you right, what you're saying is if an idea isn't from 'reason' than how can we criticize it using reason. But we can and do all the time. Religion is irrational, but we criticize it and take what is good from it and discard the rest.

#1818·​Zelalem MekonnenOP, about 1 year ago·​Criticism1 pending criticism

Religion is a form of knowledge, but it is not reasonable. It holds some truths, but it is not reasonable. Knowledge can come from myths, which are not reason.

#1734·​Zelalem MekonnenOP revised about 1 year ago·​Original #1653·​1 pending criticism

This misses the point of the post before it. Knowledge starts as myths and contains myths. Reason makes it hard to vary, thus reasonable to take as true until the myths in that theory itself are corrected.

#1726·​Zelalem MekonnenOP, over 1 year ago·​2 pending criticisms

Fire purifies gold, but it isn't gold itself. Reason doesn't need to be the source of knowledge to criticize other sources. The main source of knowledge is myth and things that don't make sense. All of our scientific theories are testable, hard to vary myths. As Popper states in Conjecture and Refutations (171), "[w]e shall understand that, in a certain sense, science is myth-making just as religion is."

#1653·​Zelalem MekonnenOP, over 1 year ago·​1 pending criticism

I thought ellipsis was including the []. But it isn't.

#1652·​Zelalem MekonnenOP, over 1 year ago

Ayn Rand claims that "[t]he virtue of Rationality means the recognition and acceptance of reason as one's only source of knowledge [...]." This is wrong, mainly because reason can only be used as a method of choosing between knowledge/ideas, not as a source of knowledge.

#1650·​Zelalem MekonnenOP revised over 1 year ago·​Original #1616

So the [...] or ellipsis indicates that the sentence is quoted half way.

#1649·​Zelalem MekonnenOP, over 1 year ago

Ayn Rand claims that "The virtue of Rationality means the recognition and acceptance of reason as one's only source of knowledge [...]." This is wrong, mainly because reason can only be used as a method of choosing between knowledge/ideas, not as a source of knowledge.

#1647·​Zelalem MekonnenOP revised over 1 year ago·​Original #1616·​Criticism2 pending criticisms

Point taken. It is copy/pasted now.

#1644·​Zelalem MekonnenOP, over 1 year ago·​1 pending criticism

The source of knowledge is myths. Reason criticizes them and we get myths that are testable (if knowledge about the physical world), hard to vary and make some assertion about reality. Popper highlighted the myth and testable nature of scientific knowledge, and Deutsch highlights hard to vary and explanation/assertion nature of knowledge.

#1633·​Zelalem MekonnenOP, over 1 year ago·​1 pending criticism

I didn't copy/paste, no. I try not to whenever possible. It helps with paying attention to the detail.

#1632·​Zelalem MekonnenOP, over 1 year ago·​1 pending criticism