Activity

  Tyler Mills criticized idea #5047.

Hmm, I'll try to formulate in another way what I was getting at, not sure if you still disagree with this:

  • My guess is that the selection mechanism can't be specified at all in the evolutionary algorithm, because every such specification is a restriction of universality. Reality has to do the selection.
#5047​·​Erik Orrje, 3 days ago

Unless I'm mistaken, Deutsch has argued that a person in total isolation from reality would still be capable of creativity. Reality is a good source of problems/niches for us, but is not necessary. It seems to me we must have sources of selection in the mind. I picture autonomous regions, or layers, each of which is like an external reality from the perspective of the others, so they all scratch each other's backs.