V
  • Activity
  • Articles New
  • Discussions
  • Chronicles
  • Search
  • Log in
  • Sign up
V

Read

  • ActivityWhat people posted
  • ArticlesNewMembers think big
  • DiscussionsIdeas open to criticism
  • ChroniclesHistory’s greatest ideas
  • SearchFind ideas by their words

Explore

  • MembersEveryone here and their badges
  • BountiesMoney offered for criticism
  • BadgesWhat there is to earn
Log inSign up

Activity

  Benjamin Davies commented on idea #5275.
Dennis Hackethal·​#1497·​over 1 year ago
How to Structure Discussions
Overall, I think the starting point of a discussion isn’t all that important as long as you’re willing to keep correcting errors. (Popper) But for those looking for a starting point, you can take inspiration from what I wrote in #502. You can either structure a discussion around a single problem: Or, if the discussion is wider than a single problem, you can treat it as a collection of problems…
#5275·​Dennis Hackethal, 3 months ago

From #1497, emphasis mine:

Discussion title: problem
Top-level ideas in the discussion: proposed solutions
Nested ideas: criticisms, counter-criticisms, and further solutions

This is what I was going off. Did I misunderstand #1497?

3 months ago·​‘What Makes One Idea Better Than Another?’

“[T]he growth of knowledge depends entirely upon disagreement.”

Karl Popper, The Myth of the Framework

Explore

  • ArticlesNew
  • Discussions
  • Members
  • Bounties
  • Badges

Learn

  • How Veritula Works
  • How Bounties Work
  • AI Assistants
  • Status

About

  • By Dennis Hackethal
  • Terms & Privacy

Veritula – A Bit of Truth

3a53a08