Activity
Dennis Hackethal addressed criticism #2138.
#2138·Dennis HackethalOP revised 12 months agoWhat reason could you have to ignore the pending criticisms and adopt [the criticized idea] anyway?
Maybe the criticisms aren’t decisive.
The argument is that we have no reason not to adopt an idea with no pending criticism. In other words, we should adopt unproblematic ideas.
A criticism can itself be such an unproblematic idea. Meaning we should adopt pending criticisms. We can’t consistently adopt an idea and its pending criticisms. So from the adoption of a pending criticism logically follows the rejection of its target idea.