Criticisms of ‘Based Brief’

Discussion started by Dennis Hackethal

  Log in or sign up to participate in this discussion.
With an account, you can revise, criticize, and comment on ideas, and submit new ideas.

One of the people running ‘Based Brief’ has requested criticism, specifically of their latest newsletter titled ‘Honduras rugpulls Próspera and other ZEDEs’. These criticisms aren’t meant to be exhaustive.


Discussions can branch out indefinitely. Zoom out for the bird’s-eye view.
Dennis Hackethal’s avatar
Dennis HackethalOP, 12 months ago·#698·· Collapse

Honduran Supreme Court declares ZEDEs unconstitutional, putting Próspera and other ZEDEs in jeopardy.

Not everyone knows what a “ZEDE” is. Is it an acronym? What does it stand for?

Criticism
Dennis Hackethal’s avatar
Dennis HackethalOP, 12 months ago·#700·· Collapse

I now see that the newsletter links to an explanation further down:

ZEDEs are SEZs in Honduras.

But that’s too late. May have already lost readers at that point.

Dirk Meulenbelt’s avatar
Dirk Meulenbelt, 12 months ago·#716·· Collapse

How could I explain a term in the headline?

Dennis Hackethal’s avatar
Dennis HackethalOP, 12 months ago·#727·· Collapse

‘Honduran Supreme Court declares zones for employment and economic development (ZEDEs) unconstitutional’

Dennis Hackethal’s avatar
1st of 2 versions

Not a lawyer but reproducing the entire letter from Próspera Zede is presumably a violation of their copyright.

CriticismCriticized1 criticim(s)
Dennis Hackethal’s avatar
Dennis HackethalOP, 12 months ago·#713·· Collapse

Superseded by #712. This comment was generated automatically.

Criticism of #699
Dennis Hackethal’s avatar
Dennis HackethalOP, 12 months ago·#701·· Collapse

Related to #700:

ZEDEs are SEZs in Honduras.

What are SEZs?

Criticism
Dirk Meulenbelt’s avatar
Dirk Meulenbelt, 12 months ago·#718·· Collapse

I suppose that too warrants an explanation.

Dennis Hackethal’s avatar
Dennis HackethalOP revised 12 months ago·#703·· Collapse
2nd of 2 versions

made […] legally possible

Just say ‘legalized’

Criticism
Dirk Meulenbelt’s avatar
Dirk Meulenbelt, 12 months ago·#719·· Collapse

Gotcha

Dennis Hackethal’s avatar
Dennis HackethalOP, 12 months ago·#705·· Collapse

achieved via allowing

‘by allowing’

Criticism
Dirk Meulenbelt’s avatar
Dirk Meulenbelt, 12 months ago·#720·· Collapse

Indeed

Dennis Hackethal’s avatar
Dennis HackethalOP, 12 months ago·#706·· Collapse

lighter taxes and regulations

‘lower taxes and lighter regulations’ (I don’t think taxes can be ‘light’)

Criticism
Dirk Meulenbelt’s avatar
Dirk Meulenbelt, 12 months ago·#721·· Collapse

I suppose not

Dennis Hackethal’s avatar
Dennis HackethalOP, 12 months ago·#707·· Collapse

Prospects for Próspera and other ZEDEs look dire and in a recent post […]

The alliteration threw me off a bit here. And if they’re dire they’re not really prospects. ‘Outlook’ might work better here.

Criticism
Dirk Meulenbelt’s avatar
Dirk Meulenbelt, 12 months ago·#722·· Collapse

Agreed

Dennis Hackethal’s avatar
Dennis HackethalOP, 12 months ago·#708·· Collapse

The Honduran Supreme Court still needs to publish an explanatory addendum on the passed law to explain how (existing) ZEDEs will be dealt with after this ruling.

Passive voice hides accountability. Who will deal with ZEDEs? Use active voice accordingly.

Criticism
Dirk Meulenbelt’s avatar
Dirk Meulenbelt, 12 months ago·#723·· Collapse

Agreed

Dennis Hackethal’s avatar
Dennis HackethalOP, 12 months ago·#709·· Collapse

Zu- series of popup projects

That hyphen looks out of place.

Criticism
Dirk Meulenbelt’s avatar
Dirk Meulenbelt, 12 months ago·#724·· Collapse

There are a bunch of things that start with Zu, such as ZuBerlin, ZuThailand, etc. I suppose that too could've been explained clearer

Dennis Hackethal’s avatar
Dennis HackethalOP, 12 months ago·#729·· Collapse

I see. It’s the hyphen being followed by a space that threw me off. Did you get that from Dutch? I know German has it, too, but I don’t think English does. ‘Zu series’ might work.

Dennis Hackethal’s avatar
Dennis HackethalOP, 12 months ago·#710·· Collapse

In the coming period, expect us to pick up on many of the talks’ subject matter.

False possessive

Criticism
Dirk Meulenbelt’s avatar
Dirk Meulenbelt, 12 months ago·#726·· Collapse

Interesting. I recall this felt 'off'. I keep learning grammar details after 20 years of knowing English.

Dennis Hackethal’s avatar
Dennis HackethalOP revised 12 months ago·#714·· Collapse
2nd of 2 versions

We will update you on news, events, and do longer form write-ups […]

‘longer-form’

[…] on the projects discussed in the talks, […]

You mentioned the talks in the previous sentence. Remove “discussed in the talks” and instead say ‘discussed projects’ or ‘projects that were discussed’.

[…] as we now have many more news sources we didn’t yet know about.

Don’t explain yourself to your readers. Remove this part.

Criticism
Dirk Meulenbelt’s avatar
Dirk Meulenbelt, 12 months ago·#725·· Collapse

agreed