Veritula – Meta

  Dennis Hackethal revised criticism #439.

Elaborate on each commit


The following commits should address this:

  • 3af3966 Clarify in title that someone revised an idea (rathen than originated idea)
  • 6c70cea Underneath idea, indicate that someone revised an idea (rather than submitted it)
  • d20d386 Explain that users can revise each others’ ideas
  • c5748e3 Turn ‘revise’ link into ‘revise their idea’ when it’s someone else’s idea
  • e0fbd41 List user under each revision in version history

The following commits should address this:

  • 3af3966 Clarify in title that someone revised an idea (rathen than originated idea)

    The HTML title now says ‘Idea x revised by…’

  • 6c70cea Underneath idea, indicate that someone revised an idea (rather than submitted it)

    It says ‘Dennis Hackethal, 1 day ago’ for new ideas, ‘Dennis Hackethal revised 1 day ago’ for revisions

  • d20d386 Explain that users can revise each others’ ideas

    As part of the alert on the revision page, when the user is about to revise someone else’s idea.

  • c5748e3 Turn ‘revise’ link into ‘revise their idea’ when it’s someone else’s idea

    Underneath each idea.

  • e0fbd41 List user under each revision in version history

    So that each version is clearly attributed to the corresponding user.

  Dennis Hackethal addressed criticism #437.

Dirk Meulenbelt says the concept of revising someone else’s idea is not intuitive.

#437·Dennis HackethalOP revised about 1 year ago

The following commits should address this:

  • 3af3966 Clarify in title that someone revised an idea (rathen than originated idea)
  • 6c70cea Underneath idea, indicate that someone revised an idea (rather than submitted it)
  • d20d386 Explain that users can revise each others’ ideas
  • c5748e3 Turn ‘revise’ link into ‘revise their idea’ when it’s someone else’s idea
  • e0fbd41 List user under each revision in version history
  Dennis Hackethal revised criticism #436.

Add missing word


Dirk Meulenbelt the concept of revising someone else’s idea is not intuitive.

Dirk Meulenbelt says the concept of revising someone else’s idea is not intuitive.

  Dennis Hackethal submitted criticism #436.

Dirk Meulenbelt the concept of revising someone else’s idea is not intuitive.

  Dennis Hackethal addressed criticism #434.

There’s a bug where right-clicking in a form to paste text doesn’t result in the preview updating.

#434·Dennis HackethalOP, about 1 year ago

Fixed as of b5d435e.

  Dennis Hackethal submitted criticism #434.

There’s a bug where right-clicking in a form to paste text doesn’t result in the preview updating.

  Dennis Hackethal revised criticism #423.

Link to revision activity with collapsed lines


Done as of cc8e3e9. It now says ‘x unchanged lines collapsed’.

Done as of cc8e3e9. It now says ‘x unchanged lines collapsed’. See eg this activity.

  Dennis Hackethal addressed criticism #424.

Would be neat linking to a specific activity.

#424·Dennis HackethalOP, about 1 year ago

Done as of a02e6c4, see eg this activity.

  Dennis Hackethal submitted criticism #424.

Would be neat linking to a specific activity.

  Dennis Hackethal addressed criticism #422.

Diffs should omit unchanged lines. Maybe just leave up to three lines around changed content for context – that’s how git does it.

#422·Dennis HackethalOP, about 1 year ago

Done as of cc8e3e9. It now says ‘x unchanged lines collapsed’.

  Dennis Hackethal submitted criticism #422.

Diffs should omit unchanged lines. Maybe just leave up to three lines around changed content for context – that’s how git does it.

  Dennis Hackethal revised criticism #419.

Now that there are user profiles (#408), each profile can have a tab for unproblematic ideas. Among all the ideas a user has submitted, those are the ones he can rationally hold. And another tab for problematic ideas, ie ideas he cannot rationally hold.

Now that there are user profiles (#408), each profile can have a tab for unproblematic ideas. Among all the ideas a user has submitted, those are the ones he can rationally hold. And another tab for problematic ideas, ie ideas he has submitted that he cannot rationally hold.

  Dennis Hackethal submitted criticism #419.

Now that there are user profiles (#408), each profile can have a tab for unproblematic ideas. Among all the ideas a user has submitted, those are the ones he can rationally hold. And another tab for problematic ideas, ie ideas he cannot rationally hold.

  Dennis Hackethal submitted criticism #417.

There’s a bug where hovering over a link in the markdown preview removes the form and all typed text. Hovering over a link should have no effect on the form.

  Dennis Hackethal addressed criticism #414.

Since the diff processes the text as a single line, the hunk header is always going to say either @@ -0,0 +1 @@ (for the first version) or @@ -1 +1 @@ (for every subsequent version). Meaning the header provides no real information. So I might as well remove it.

#414·Dennis HackethalOP revised about 1 year ago

Done as of 8d3eed0, see eg the version history of #414.

  Dennis Hackethal revised criticism #413.

Since the diff processes the text as a single line, the diff information is always going to say either @@ -0,0 +1 @@ (for the first version) or @@ -1 +1 @@ (for every subsequent version). Meaning it provides no real information. So I might as well remove that part.

Since the diff processes the text as a single line, the hunk header is always going to say either @@ -0,0 +1 @@ (for the first version) or @@ -1 +1 @@ (for every subsequent version). Meaning the header provides no real information. So I might as well remove it.

  Dennis Hackethal submitted criticism #413.

Since the diff processes the text as a single line, the diff information is always going to say either @@ -0,0 +1 @@ (for the first version) or @@ -1 +1 @@ (for every subsequent version). Meaning it provides no real information. So I might as well remove that part.

  Dennis Hackethal addressed criticism #408.

There should be user profiles.

#408·Dennis HackethalOP, about 1 year ago

Done as of b3c06c4, see eg my profile.

  Dennis Hackethal submitted criticism #408.

There should be user profiles.

  Dennis Hackethal addressed criticism #355.

In activity feed, behind timestamp (‘… hours ago’), link to corresponding discussion.

#355·Dennis HackethalOP, over 1 year ago

Done as of e3f2c5b.

  Dennis Hackethal submitted criticism #355.

In activity feed, behind timestamp (‘… hours ago’), link to corresponding discussion.

  Dennis Hackethal addressed criticism #349.

The activity feed just shows top-level criticisms as regular ideas. They should be shown as criticisms just like when they are child ideas.

#349·Dennis HackethalOP revised over 1 year ago

Done as of c11a13c.

  Dennis Hackethal addressed criticism #337.

When all I change during a revision is the criticism flag, the activity log just says ‘no changes’.

#337·Dennis HackethalOP, over 1 year ago

As of 9702c05, a revision activity now says that the idea was either marked or unmarked as a criticism.

  Dennis Hackethal addressed criticism #351.

When a comment is a criticism on another criticism, the activity should say ‘So and so addressed criticism #…’

#351·Dennis HackethalOP, over 1 year ago

Done as of 735c3cc.

  Dennis Hackethal submitted criticism #351.

When a comment is a criticism on another criticism, the activity should say ‘So and so addressed criticism #…’