Abortion

See full discussion
  Log in or sign up to participate in this discussion.
With an account, you can revise, criticize, and comment on ideas.

Discussions can branch out indefinitely. Zoom out for the bird’s-eye view.

It’s not right to force a parent to take care of a child they didn’t want. The result is often tragic. Abortion relieves parents of that responsibility and prevents this outcome. Parents don’t owe their children anything, and children don’t owe their parents anything.

(Amaro)

#130 · · Dennis HackethalOP, 10 months ago · context · Criticized4 criticim(s)

Parents facing the consequences of their actions isn’t “force”.

#149 · · Dennis HackethalOP revised 10 months ago · 2nd of 2 versions · Criticism of #130
#149 · expand

The result is often tragic. Abortion relieves parents of that responsibility and prevents this outcome.

Adoption

#132 · · Dennis HackethalOP, 10 months ago · Criticism of #130
#132 · expand

Parents don’t owe their children anything […].

Yes they do. They are responsible for bringing a helpless being into the world who depends on them.

#133 · · Dennis HackethalOP, 10 months ago · Criticism of #130

depends whether the mother took measures to not get pregnant, if she did and still got pregnant - less responsibility

#228 · · Dennis HackethalOP revised 10 months ago · 2nd of 2 versions · Criticism of #133Criticized1 criticim(s)

She was neither forced nor tricked. She took an action which she knew (or should have known) comes with certain risks. The risks materialized. That doesn’t make her any less responsible.

On the contrary, per my suggestion, she had six weeks to monitor whether she was pregnant. That’s long enough to miss her period, which is a huge warning sign she’d have to be extremely dishonest about with herself to just ignore. During those six weeks, she could have unilaterally decided to get an abortion safely and with impunity. She instead chose to ignore her pregnancy, evade it, not do anything about it, whatever.

Her body, her choice, her responsibility. #171, #172

#230 · · Dennis HackethalOP, 10 months ago · Criticism of #228
#230 · expand
#228 · expand
#133 · expand

We already have laws for how to deal with neglect.

(Danny)

#151 · · Dennis HackethalOP, 10 months ago · Criticism of #130
#151 · expand
#130 · expand