Copyright

See full discussion
  Log in or sign up to participate in this discussion.
With an account, you can revise, criticize, and comment on ideas.

Discussions can branch out indefinitely. Zoom out for the bird’s-eye view.

I doubt it. I hope they keep doing it. I hope to live in a world where copyright isn't enforced. I expect to see more creation and novelty.

#1413 · · Amaro Koberle, about 1 month ago · context · CriticismCriticized3 criticim(s)

Duplicate of #1329.

#1414 · · Dennis Hackethal, about 1 month ago · Criticism of #1413
#1414 · expand

I doubt it.

Unclear what “it” refers to.

#1415 · · Dennis Hackethal, about 1 month ago · Criticism of #1413
#1415 · expand

I doubt it.

You just say that without any reasoning.

#1416 · · Dennis Hackethal, about 1 month ago · Criticism of #1413

Midjourney wouldn't exist... Our cool pics of Mujahideen eating Bacon wouldn't exist.

#1417 · · Amaro Koberle, about 1 month ago · Criticism of #1416Criticized2 criticim(s)
#1418 · · Dennis Hackethal, about 1 month ago · Criticism of #1417
#1418 · expand

‘Couriers who jump start their careers by stealing bicycles wouldn’t exist.’

#1419 · · Dennis Hackethal, about 1 month ago · Criticism of #1417

It's a good point, but I don't think those two compare. Again, bicycles are scarce. My use prevents your use.

#1421 · · Amaro Koberle revised about 1 month ago · 2nd of 2 versions · Criticism of #1419Criticized3 criticim(s)

Duplicate of #1346.

#1423 · · Dennis Hackethal, about 1 month ago · Criticism of #1421
#1423 · expand

It’s about value not physical scarcity. If you only steal it while I’m asleep and return it before I wake up and want to use it it’s still theft.

#1424 · · Dennis Hackethal, about 1 month ago · Criticism of #1421
#1424 · expand

There's this nice bit in Man, Economy & State where Rothbard explains that durable goods can be broken down into their unit services (not sure that's the term) and that all durable goods get used up as they provide service.

So I guess someone would reduce the serviceable lifespan of the bike by using it during the times that you aren't using it.

#1425 · · Amaro Koberle, about 1 month ago · Criticism of #1421

Yeah. And if he takes it against your will and replaces it with a brand new bike it’s still theft.

#1426 · · Dennis Hackethal, about 1 month ago
#1426 · expand
#1425 · expand
#1421 · expand
#1419 · expand
#1417 · expand
#1416 · expand
#1413 · expand