Abortion

See full discussion
  Log in or sign up to participate in this discussion.
With an account, you can revise, criticize, and comment on ideas.

Discussions can branch out indefinitely. Zoom out for the bird’s-eye view.

I think it’s not okay to kill someone whose nervous system stops working later in life if it may work again.
They’ve already been a person and may well continue to be a person. That can’t be said of an organism that has never had a nervous system.

#208 · · Dennis HackethalOP revised 11 months ago · context · 2nd of 2 versions · Criticism

But if an accident removes the entire brain yet the body somehow stays alive like a vegetable, then yeah I’d say it’s okay to pull the plug.
Is that fair? It’s interesting how abortion and euthanasia are kind of related in this way.

#210 · · Dennis HackethalOP, 11 months ago
#210 · expand

It’s arbitrary. A functioning nervous system does not imply complex thought.

#211 · · Dennis HackethalOP, 11 months ago · Criticism of #208Criticized1 criticim(s)

Right, but the absence of a functioning nervous system implies the absence of sentience [see #107]. So I don’t think it’s arbitrary.

#212 · · Dennis HackethalOP, 11 months ago · Criticism of #211
#212 · expand
#211 · expand
#208 · expand