Veritula – Meta

Showing only #2912 and its comments.

See full discussion
  Log in or sign up to participate in this discussion.
With an account, you can revise, criticize, and comment on ideas.

Discussions can branch out indefinitely. Zoom out for the bird’s-eye view.
Dennis Hackethal’s avatar

‘Discussions’ are too narrow a term for a collection of ideas. See #2878.

While ideas should always be ‘discussable’, that doesn’t mean everyone who wants to share an idea always wants to start a discussion. Maybe they just want to put some information out there.

Criticism
Dennis Hackethal’s avatar

‘Topic’

Criticized1
Benjamin Davies’s avatar
Benjamin Davies, 22 days ago·#2934

This makes me think of “discussion topic”.

Criticism of #2913
Dennis Hackethal’s avatar

‘Thread’

Criticized1
Benjamin Davies’s avatar
Benjamin Davies, 22 days ago·#2933

Similar to ‘discussion’.

Criticism of #2914
Dennis Hackethal’s avatar

Why is similarity a bad thing in and of itself? It can be reminiscent of discussions as long as it’s less narrow.

Criticism of #2933Criticized1
Benjamin Davies’s avatar
Benjamin Davies, 22 days ago·#2941

Similarity is fine if it is less narrow, but ‘thread’ doesn’t seem any less narrow than ‘discussion’ to me. A ‘thread’ usually means a reply chain.

Criticism of #2940
Dennis Hackethal’s avatar

‘Subject’

Criticized2
Benjamin Davies’s avatar
Benjamin Davies, 22 days ago·#2936

I have an inexplicit criticism of this relating to “school subject”.

Criticism of #2915
Benjamin Davies’s avatar
Benjamin Davies, 22 days ago·#2937

Makes me think of “subject of discussion”.

Criticism of #2915
Dennis Hackethal’s avatar

‘Space’

Criticized1
Dennis Hackethal’s avatar

Sounds like a voice chat (like Twitter spaces)

Criticism of #2916
Dennis Hackethal’s avatar

‘Entry’

Criticized1
Benjamin Davies’s avatar
Benjamin Davies, 22 days ago·#2939

I can’t decide if this communicates a grouping of ideas. Seems borderline.

Criticism of #2917
Dennis Hackethal’s avatar

‘Note’

Criticized1
Dennis Hackethal’s avatar

Doesn’t communicate a grouping of ideas.

Criticism of #2918
Dennis Hackethal’s avatar

‘Post’

Criticized1
Dennis Hackethal’s avatar

Doesn’t communicate a grouping of ideas.

Criticism of #2919
Dennis Hackethal’s avatar

‘Piece’

Criticized1
Dennis Hackethal’s avatar

Doesn’t communicate a grouping of ideas.

Criticism of #2920
Dennis Hackethal’s avatar

‘Context’

Criticized1
Benjamin Davies’s avatar
Benjamin Davies, 22 days ago·#2928

Too jargon-y.

Criticism of #2921
Benjamin Davies’s avatar
Benjamin Davies, 22 days ago·#2938

“Go check out the Karl Popper context on Veritula” would only make sense if you are already a Veritula user who is accustomed to using this terminology.

Dennis Hackethal’s avatar

‘Cluster’

Criticized1
Benjamin Davies’s avatar
Benjamin Davies, 22 days ago·#2935

This actually seems anti-discussion. Sounds like a grouping of ideas that are only related by conceptual proximity, rather than building on each other.

Criticism of #2922