Should There Be a Minimum Wage?

Showing only #6149 and its comments.

See full discussion
  Log in or sign up to participate in this discussion.
With an account, you can revise, criticize, and comment on ideas.

Discussions can branch out indefinitely. You may need to scroll sideways.
Dennis Hackethal’s avatar
Dennis HackethalOP·​#6149·​

Effective or not, at least the advocates of the minimum wage have good intentions.

4 pending criticisms
Dennis Hackethal’s avatar
Dennis HackethalOP·​#6150·​·​Criticism

One of the great mistakes is to judge policies and programs by their intentions rather than their results. We all know a famous road that is paved with good intentions.

The people who go around talking about their soft heart …, it very often extends to their head as well, because … the programs that are labeled as being for the poor, for the needy, almost always have effects exactly the opposite of those which their well-intentioned sponsors intend them to have.

Dennis Hackethal’s avatar
Dennis HackethalOP·​#6151·​·​Criticism

No, minimum-wage laws have originally racist motivations in several jurisdictions:

  • British Columbia, a minimum-wage law passed in 1925 to price Japanese immigrants out of jobs in lumber.
  • Australia, to “‘protect the white Australian’s standard of living from the invidious competition of the colored races, particularly of the Chinese,’ who were willing to work for less.”
  • South Africa during apartheid, when “white labor unions urged that a minimum-wage law be applied to all races, to keep black workers from taking jobs away from white unionized workers by working for less than the union pay scale.”
  • The United States, with the Davis-Bacon Act of 1931, whose supporters “used exactly the same rationale, citing the fact that Southern construction companies, using non-union black workers, were able to come north and under-bid construction companies using unionized white labor.”

Historically, advocates of the minimum wage understood its effects and used them strategically.

Linked to by #6152
Dennis Hackethal’s avatar
Dennis HackethalOP·​#6152·​·​Criticism

Related to #6151, unions in particular use the minimum wage for evil:

Labor unions have been supporters of minimum-wage laws in countries around the world, since these laws price non-union workers out of jobs, leaving more jobs for union members.

Thomas Sowell, ‘Minimum-Wage Laws Have Consequences’, 2013, National Review
Dennis Hackethal’s avatar
Dennis HackethalOP·​#6153·​·​Criticism

Sowell also argues:

If [today’s advocates of the minimum wage] thought things through, how could they have imagined that having large numbers of idle teenage boys hanging out on the streets together would be good for any community — especially in places where most of these youngsters were raised by single mothers, another unintended consequence, in this case, of well-meaning welfare policies?

Thomas Sowell, ‘Minimum-Wage Laws Have Consequences’, 2013, National Review

And, as mentioned in #6148, minimum-wage laws have had “devastating effects … on black teenage unemployment rates” in particular.

So it’s especially contradictory to advocate minimum-wage laws on social-justice grounds.

  • Rationally adoptable.
  • Not rationally adoptable.
  • Older versions with pending criticisms.
  • Ideas are blue, criticisms red, comments small and gray.
  • Hover over ideas to expand them.
  • Click on ideas to jump to their place in the discussion.