Search

Words match in any order. "many worlds" matches the phrase exactly; -gravity excludes ideas with “gravity”.

Ideas that are…

Search Ideas


914 ideas match your query.:

Thank you for clarifying this. The idea of submitting a criticism and also immediately revising makes sense.

The criticisms you shared today (that inspired me to post #2884) are valid. This question came out of confusion as to how Veritula is intended to be used, rather than frustration directed at you.

#2893·​Benjamin Davies, about 1 year ago·​Archived

The purpose of the reaction would be to record a kind of agreement or acknowledgment.
That way, Veritula could show ‘pending’ criticisms to users, say – ‘pending’ in the sense that they haven’t responded to those criticisms. So in addition to revising or counter-criticizing, they get a chance to accept a criticism without it remaining in a ‘pending’ state.

Posting arbitrary emojis doesn’t achieve that purpose.

#2892·​Dennis HackethalOP, about 1 year ago·​Criticism2 pending criticismsArchived

There are a few reasons people might send criticisms instead of revising an idea themselves:

  1. You get a chance to disagree.
  2. Submitting a criticism is easier.
  3. A criticism is a written record explaining why a revision is necessary.

Because of the third reason, you may see people post a criticism and then immediately revise your idea to address it.

Maybe I’m wrong but I’m sensing a bit of frustration between the lines. Please note that Veritula pursues a higher standard of error correction than other platforms. Some criticisms may be unexpected; discussions could go in a direction you did not anticipate. You may receive criticisms that would be deemed nitpicky on other platforms, but they’re not meant to be. They may go beyond what’s strictly socially acceptable. I intend criticism to be a gift to you. For ‘small’ criticisms, it’s usually best to revise accordingly and not counter-criticize.

Your idea reads more like a question than a criticism. But since I’ve (hopefully) answered it, I’m marking this response a criticism to neutralize it.

#2889·​Dennis HackethalOP, about 1 year ago·​CriticismArchived

Sorry, I was debugging something and temporarily disabled this feature. Should be back up.

#2888·​Dennis HackethalOP, about 1 year ago·​CriticismArchived

This is no longer working for me.

#2887·​Benjamin Davies, about 1 year ago·​Criticism1 pending criticismArchived

I am currently unable to zoom out to the full width when accessing Veritula on mobile.

#2886·​Benjamin Davies, about 1 year ago·​Criticism1 pending criticismArchived

Ah I see.

#2885·​Benjamin Davies, about 1 year ago·​Archived

Since users are able to revise other users’ ideas, why is it standard practice on Veritula to submit trivial improvements to ideas (such as correction of typos, poor grammar and redundancies) as criticisms, rather than directly revising the idea itself? Example: #2865

Perhaps I have misunderstood the intention of enabling users to revise other people’s ideas.

#2884·​Benjamin Davies, about 1 year ago·​Criticism1 pending criticismArchived

Continuing on from #2882, would it make sense to enable users to criticise the discussion/entry/topic, such that it would render a criticism pill?

#2883·​Benjamin Davies, about 1 year ago·​Archived

If ‘discussions’ take on a broader form, like we have discussed up to #2880, would this change? What if a user wishes to express that they take issue with something written in the entry/topic body text? I suppose they would quote it in their top-level criticism.

#2882·​Benjamin Davies, about 1 year ago·​Archived

Given #2877, will this still be the case?

#2881·​Benjamin Davies, about 1 year ago·​Criticism1 pending criticismArchived

So I’m open to replacing the word ‘discussion’ with a more general word. It should still communicate a sort of ‘grouping’ of ideas but need not be as narrow as ‘discussion’. Would that help?

Certainly. I think this makes a lot sense.

I think ‘entry’ is my favourite of the ones you mentioned (and of some others I explored with Gemini). ‘Topic’ is also alright, but seems more leading than ‘entry’. I like ‘entry’ because it seems the most agnostic to user intent, while also working fine with UI elements.

#2880·​Benjamin Davies, about 1 year ago·​Archived

I still think that Veritula already offers what you want – posting a single, top-level idea that is structured any way you like, to a new discussion whose title can be as open-ended as you like – but I’m sympathetic to your motivation.

Not every user is always interested in starting a discussion. Maybe they just want to put some information out there. And although others should still be able to discuss that information, criticism chains and all, that may not always be their primary motivation for posting the information in the first place.

So I’m open to replacing the word ‘discussion’ with a more general word. It should still communicate a sort of ‘grouping’ of ideas but need not be as narrow as ‘discussion’. Would that help?

ChatGPT suggestions:

Topic, thread, subject, space, entry, note / post / piece, context, cluster.

It’s also worth considering what each word would sound like in terms of UI elements. For example, ‘Start a new topic’, ‘Share a space’, etc.

#2878·​Dennis HackethalOP, about 1 year ago·​Archived

You wrote in #2856:

… is there anything wrong with just titling a discussion 'Karl Popper' and then putting the equivalent of an encyclopedia article in the about section?

If you are willing to do that, I don’t see the need for this new feature.

#2877·​Dennis HackethalOP, about 1 year ago·​CriticismArchived

See #2765. People can make discussions as general as they want. So there need not be any silo-ing.

#2876·​Dennis HackethalOP, about 1 year ago·​CriticismArchived

… is there anything wrong with just titling a discussion 'Karl Popper' and then putting the equivalent of an encyclopedia article in the about section?

About sections are for context or background info, not content.

#2875·​Dennis HackethalOP, about 1 year ago·​CriticismArchived

… is there anything wrong with just titling a discussion 'Karl Popper' and then putting the equivalent of an encyclopedia article in the about section?

Yes. About sections can’t be part of criticism chains.

#2874·​Dennis HackethalOP, about 1 year ago·​CriticismArchived

They’re not supposed to, see #2871.

#2873·​Dennis HackethalOP, about 1 year ago·​CriticismArchived

Since discussions themselves are criticisable…

They’re not, see #2871.

#2872·​Dennis HackethalOP, about 1 year ago·​CriticismArchived

I am struggling to understand what it means to criticise a discussion.

Top-level criticisms don’t criticize the discussion as a whole. They’re just criticisms of something. Anything. It depends on context.

For example, top-level criticisms in the Veritula – Meta discussion are often bug reports. So they’re criticisms of Veritula.

#2871·​Dennis HackethalOP, about 1 year ago·​CriticismArchived

Doesn’t sound as serious/legitimate as I’d like in this context.

#2867·​Dennis HackethalOP, about 1 year ago·​CriticismArchived

lead

led

#2865·​Dennis HackethalOP, about 1 year ago·​CriticismArchived

The user could publish it as a separate independent idea, including a link to the idea they want to relate/refer to.

Posting a sibling on an existing discussion is far easier.

#2863·​Dennis HackethalOP revised about 1 year ago·​Original #2862·​CriticismArchived

The user could publish it as a separate independent idea, including a link to the idea they want to relate/refer to.

Posting a sibling on an existing discussion is far easier.

#2862·​Dennis HackethalOP, about 1 year ago·​1 pending criticismArchived

That’s what notifications are for. You’d want to hit the bell icon for each discussion and at the top of the page listing all discussions. Then you’ll be notified of every activity on existing discussions, and of new discussions. The notification page keeps track of read vs unread notifications.

#2861·​Dennis HackethalOP revised about 1 year ago·​Original #2770·​CriticismArchived