Veritula – Meta

Showing only ideas leading to #5151.

See full discussion​·​See most recent related ideas
  Log in or sign up to participate in this discussion.
With an account, you can revise, criticize, and comment on ideas.
Discussions can branch out indefinitely. You may need to scroll sideways.
Tyler Mills’s avatar
Tyler Mills​·​#5148

I question whether previous versions of a criticism should contribute to the battle-tested count, as they do currently. Someone can make a spelling correction to the criticism, which creates the "supersedes" criticism of that previous version of the criticism, and that then contributes to the battle-tested count. This seems wrong, since that counter-criticism is not substantive, and even if it were, OP only generally responds to the latest version of a criticism (may not even have known about previous versions; all of this happened in: https://veritula.com/ideas/5089-knowledge-growth-such-as-in-genes-in-the-biospher).

Criticized2*
Tyler Mills’s avatar
Tyler Mills​·​#5149
Only version leading to #5151 (2 total)

But sometimes revisions can be substantive, and OP could defend against one version, and in that case it should count to the battle-tested badge!

Criticism of #5148Criticized1*
Tyler Mills’s avatar
Tyler Mills​·​#5151

Superseded by #5150. This comment was generated automatically.

Criticism of #5149