Activity Feed
Artists can focus on making art early on when they are starting out.
Imagine a singer in Nashville that is just starting out. If they are able to find a minimum wage that is decent enough for them not to think about having a good place to live and having good meals, they can instead focus on making music.
#6126·Dennis HackethalOP, 8 days ago·AI-assistedThe government should protect the poor. The rich can look after themselves, but the poor have nothing to fall back on and must depend on the state. Since most wage earners are poor, the government should protect them, including by making sure their wages are enough to live on.
Pope Leo XIII made this argument in his 1891 encyclical Rerum Novarum. He wrote that wage-earners “should be specially cared for and protected by the government” (§37), and that wages “ought not to be insufficient to support a frugal and well-behaved wage-earner” (§45).
Since most wage earners are poor, the government should protect them, including by making sure their wages are enough to live on.
If I would like to work some job for $10/hour, but the state says I can’t accept the job for less than $11, at which rate it is not being offered, then the state is dooming me to be unemployed. It’s become my destroyer, not my protector.
#6126·Dennis HackethalOP, 8 days ago·AI-assistedThe government should protect the poor. The rich can look after themselves, but the poor have nothing to fall back on and must depend on the state. Since most wage earners are poor, the government should protect them, including by making sure their wages are enough to live on.
Pope Leo XIII made this argument in his 1891 encyclical Rerum Novarum. He wrote that wage-earners “should be specially cared for and protected by the government” (§37), and that wages “ought not to be insufficient to support a frugal and well-behaved wage-earner” (§45).
must depend on the state.
The poor would have more voluntary charities to fall back if the welfare state hadn’t crowded them out. There used to be a flourishing network of charity organizations until the emergence of the mega welfare state in the 1960s.
#6126·Dennis HackethalOP, 8 days ago·AI-assistedThe government should protect the poor. The rich can look after themselves, but the poor have nothing to fall back on and must depend on the state. Since most wage earners are poor, the government should protect them, including by making sure their wages are enough to live on.
Pope Leo XIII made this argument in his 1891 encyclical Rerum Novarum. He wrote that wage-earners “should be specially cared for and protected by the government” (§37), and that wages “ought not to be insufficient to support a frugal and well-behaved wage-earner” (§45).
the poor have nothing to fall back on and must depend on the state.
That doesn’t follow.
#6114·Dennis HackethalOP revised 8 days ago·AI-assistedNobody who works full time should be poor. Yet a full-time minimum-wage earner with two kids still falls below the poverty line, so the minimum wage should be raised.
Barack Obama made this argument in his 2013 State of the Union address, declaring that “no one who works full-time should have to live in poverty.”
the minimum wage should be raised.
You can’t make someone richer by upping a number on a piece of paper. It’s a naive and mystical idea. The only legitimate way people get richer is by finding common preferences. That takes creativity, not the mechanical raising of numbers by fait/law. You can’t outlaw poverty. If you want people to get richer, reduce regulatory hurdles to make it easier for them to find common preferences.
The government should protect the poor. The rich can look after themselves, but the poor have nothing to fall back on and must depend on the state. Since most wage earners are poor, the government should protect them, including by making sure their wages are enough to live on.
Pope Leo XIII made this argument in his 1891 encyclical Rerum Novarum. He wrote that wage-earners “should be specially cared for and protected by the government” (§37), and that wages “ought not to be insufficient to support a frugal and well-behaved wage-earner” (§45).
#6114·Dennis HackethalOP revised 8 days ago·AI-assistedNobody who works full time should be poor. Yet a full-time minimum-wage earner with two kids still falls below the poverty line, so the minimum wage should be raised.
Barack Obama made this argument in his 2013 State of the Union address, declaring that “no one who works full-time should have to live in poverty.”
Yet a full-time minimum-wage earner with two kids still falls below the poverty line, so the minimum wage should be raised.
That approach would at best treat symptoms, not the root cause. If prices are too high for people to afford basic things, the government should take a look in the mirror. It artificially raises prices through taxes, inflation, and bureaucracy.
This argument rests on the implicit idea that CEOs ‘steal’ value from their employees. That isn’t the case. Theft means taking someone’s property without consent. Employees instead voluntarily enter employment because they value the wages more than whatever else they have considered doing with their time instead.
cutting executive pay
This suggestion rests on the implicit idea that evil CEOs ‘steal’ value from their employees. That isn’t the case. Theft means taking someone’s property without consent. Employees instead voluntarily enter employment because they value the wages more than whatever else they have considered doing with their time instead.
Employment isn’t some abusive relationship where profit is ‘extracted’ from the employee. Under free-market conditions, the employer hires the employee, and the employee seeks employment from said employer, because both profit from the employment. A minimum wage, on the other hand, makes it harder for both to profit.
so the money to pay workers more is there
Even if this argument were true, it doesn’t address the vast majority of businesses struggling to get by. The owners of mom-and-pop shops don’t make millions. Many businesses in affected industries (retail, restaurants) have razor-thin margins.
so the money to pay workers more is there
Even if #6118 were true, it doesn’t address the vast majority of businesses struggling to get by. The owners of mom-and-pop shops don’t make millions. Many businesses in affected industries (retail, restaurants) have razor-thin margins.
#6118·Dennis HackethalOP, 8 days ago·AI-assistedEmployers who can’t afford the higher wage have to let some workers go
Employers could pay for the higher wage by cutting executive pay instead of jobs. Many companies pay their CEOs millions, so the money to pay workers more is there, and laying workers off is a choice, not a necessity.
so the money to pay workers more is there
Even if this argument were true, it doesn’t address the vast majority of businesses struggling to get by. The owners of mom-and-pop shops don’t make millions. Many businesses in affected industries (retail, restaurants) have razor-thin margins.
#6118·Dennis HackethalOP, 8 days ago·AI-assistedEmployers who can’t afford the higher wage have to let some workers go
Employers could pay for the higher wage by cutting executive pay instead of jobs. Many companies pay their CEOs millions, so the money to pay workers more is there, and laying workers off is a choice, not a necessity.
This argument rests on the implicit idea that CEOs ‘steal’ value from their employees. That isn’t the case. Theft means taking someone’s property without consent. Employees instead voluntarily enter employment because they value the wages more than whatever else they have considered doing with their time instead.
#6117·Dennis HackethalOP, 8 days ago·AI-assistedRaising the minimum wage would lift the incomes of millions of working families.
A higher minimum wage can lower incomes instead. Employers who can’t afford the higher wage have to let some workers go, and those workers then make less than before ($0), not more.
Employers who can’t afford the higher wage have to let some workers go
Employers could pay for the higher wage by cutting executive pay instead of jobs. Many companies pay their CEOs millions, so the money to pay workers more is there, and laying workers off is a choice, not a necessity.
#6116·Dennis HackethalOP, 8 days ago·AI-assistedRaising the minimum wage would lift the incomes of millions of working families. For those families, it could mean the difference between groceries and the food bank, or between paying rent and being evicted.
Barack Obama made this argument in his 2013 State of the Union address, saying that raising the federal minimum wage to $9 an hour would “raise the incomes of millions of working families.”
Raising the minimum wage would lift the incomes of millions of working families.
A higher minimum wage can lower incomes instead. Employers who can’t afford the higher wage have to let some workers go, and those workers then make less than before ($0), not more.
Raising the minimum wage would lift the incomes of millions of working families. For those families, it could mean the difference between groceries and the food bank, or between paying rent and being evicted.
Barack Obama made this argument in his 2013 State of the Union address, saying that raising the federal minimum wage to $9 an hour would “raise the incomes of millions of working families.”
Split off the factual claim that raising the minimum wage would lift millions of families’ incomes into its own idea.
A minimum wage reduces poverty. Nobody who works full time should be poor, yet a full-time minimum-wage earner with two kids still falls below the poverty line. Raising the minimum wage would lift the incomes of millions of working families.
Barack Obama made this argument in his 2013 State of the Union address, declaring that “no one who works full-time should have to live in poverty.”
Nobody who works full time should be poor. Yet a full-time minimum-wage earner with two kids still falls below the poverty line, so the minimum wage should be raised.
Barack Obama made this argument in his 2013 State of the Union address, declaring that “no one who works full-time should have to live in poverty.”
Added a blockquote of the passage I’m criticizing.
Why shouldn’t someone who works full time be poor? This idea assumes that working full time entitles a person to a certain income, but on what grounds? I could work full time doing something nobody wants to pay me for. Why would the hours I put in entitle me to pay above a government-set floor?
Nobody who works full time should be poor
Why shouldn’t someone who works full time be poor? This idea assumes that working full time entitles a person to a certain income, but on what grounds? I could work full time doing something nobody wants to pay me for. Why would the hours I put in entitle me to pay above a government-set floor?
#6110·Dennis HackethalOP, 8 days ago·AI-assistedA minimum wage reduces poverty. Nobody who works full time should be poor, yet a full-time minimum-wage earner with two kids still falls below the poverty line. Raising the minimum wage would lift the incomes of millions of working families.
Barack Obama made this argument in his 2013 State of the Union address, declaring that “no one who works full-time should have to live in poverty.”
Why shouldn’t someone who works full time be poor? This idea assumes that working full time entitles a person to a certain income, but on what grounds? I could work full time doing something nobody wants to pay me for. Why would the hours I put in entitle me to pay above a government-set floor?
A minimum wage reduces poverty. Nobody who works full time should be poor, yet a full-time minimum-wage earner with two kids still falls below the poverty line. Raising the minimum wage would lift the incomes of millions of working families.
Barack Obama made this argument in his 2013 State of the Union address, declaring that “no one who works full-time should have to live in poverty.”
Minimum wage laws are defended on many grounds: reducing poverty, offsetting employers’ bargaining power, boosting consumer demand, cutting reliance on welfare, and more.
This discussion collects every argument for the minimum wage, one per idea, so each can be criticized on its own merits. If a pro argument is missing, post it as a new idea; if you think a criticism fails, reply to it.
#6107·Anders Kaae Hvelplund, 9 days agoLet's jive on this one. What factually accurate epistemology texts/videos gives us good descriptions of "the people condition" - sounds awkard - in the meaning of "the human condition" and/or how humans work?
Do Popper’s and Deutsch’s books not count?
Highlighted passages now have small imperfections, like when you physically drag a highlighter across a line of text on a piece of paper 🤩 Note the slight wobble and the varying angles and thickness.

#6105·Dennis Hackethal, 10 days agoFiction is the best material
Why fiction and not factually accurate epistemology?
Let's jive on this one. What factually accurate epistemology texts/videos gives us good descriptions of "the people condition" - sounds awkard - in the meaning of "the human condition" and/or how humans work?
#6104·Dennis Hackethal, 10 days agoHi Anders, welcome to V 👋
To get started, take a look at the existing discussions or read How Veritula Works.
Which discussion interests you the most?
Thanks buddy... will do!
Fiction is the best material
Why fiction and not factually accurate epistemology?
Hi Anders, welcome to V 👋
To get started, take a look at the existing discussions or read How Veritula Works.
Which discussion interests you the most?