Search

Words match in any order. "many worlds" matches the phrase exactly; -gravity excludes ideas with “gravity”.

Ideas that are…

Search Ideas


4697 ideas match your query.:

Short videos prevent the depth of explanation that long-form content can provide.

#6087·​Moritz WallawitschOP, 25 days ago·​AI-assisted·​Criticism1 pending criticism

Which conflicting preferences are involved? Why assume stopping expresses the person’s real preference, rather than treating both preferences as ideas to examine?

#6086·​Moritz WallawitschOP, 26 days ago·​AI-assisted·​Criticism

People sometimes keep watching these feeds while also wanting to stop. That conflicts with the claim that the feed is serving their interests.

#6085·​Moritz WallawitschOP, 26 days ago·​AI-assisted·​Criticism1 pending criticism

True, but serving curiosity is one way to sustain engagement. What separates engagement that serves curiosity from engagement that does not?

#6084·​Moritz WallawitschOP, 26 days ago·​AI-assisted·​Criticism

Recommendation engines optimize engagement and time spent, not curiosity. Engagement is not always curiosity.

#6083·​Moritz WallawitschOP, 26 days ago·​AI-assisted·​Criticism1 pending criticism

Personalized short-video feeds such as TikTok, Reels and YouTube Shorts are better at serving curiosity than fixed, long-form films. They adapt to your interests instead of fixing a sequence.

#6082·​Moritz WallawitschOP, 26 days ago·​AI-assisted·​ Battle-tested · 3

I was tired of slow, bloated Spotlight.

Then it hit me: I didn’t have to wait for Apple to fix it. I could just have Claude whip up an alternative.

Meet Blink: results in under 17ms vs. up to 1,083ms for Spotlight. Free and open source.

Download and install:

A fast Spotlight replacement for macOS that does just two things: opens apps and does math. - dchacke/blink

See demo:

#6081·​Dennis Hackethal, 26 days ago·​AI-assisted

How do we decide which test is more severe? That judgment seems to do the work of forming the preference here. The criticism tree records the judgment, but what explains how we reach it?

#6080·​Moritz Wallawitsch, 27 days ago·​AI-assisted·​Criticism1 pending criticism

The requirement to have ‘programmed it’ is imprecise. Would precise pseudocode count, or must it be executable code? If pseudocode fully specifies the procedure, what additional understanding does translating it into Python require?

#6079·​Moritz Wallawitsch, 27 days ago·​AI-assisted·​Criticism

This rules out partial understanding. I understand aspects of how capitalism works even though I couldn’t build a faithful simulation of a capitalist economy. Not having programmed preference formation doesn’t show that Popper understood nothing about it. What specific part did he fail to understand?

#6078·​Moritz Wallawitsch, 27 days ago·​AI-assisted·​Criticism2 pending criticisms

New on V: a guide that walks you through your rejectable ideas and helps you rehabilitate them.

Check it from time to time to ensure harmony between your thoughts and your actions.

In addition, every rejectable idea on the site now has a ‘Rehabilitate’ link to the same guiding mechanism so you can help other people rehabilitate their ideas.

Try it today: https://veritula.com/guide

#6077·​Dennis Hackethal, 27 days ago

New on Veritula: criticized passages get red, overlapping highlights. Comments get gray.

See at a glance which parts of an idea are problematic:

#6076·​Dennis Hackethal, 27 days ago

Tags on discussions would solve the same problem with less. A discussion could carry several tags, and nothing would need its own pages, moderators or membership. Subreddits come with all of that.

#6075·​Dennis HackethalOP, 28 days ago·​AI-assisted·​Criticism

Idea: communities.
Discussions vary widely, but people gather around topics, like nutrition or software engineering. Communities would group discussions by topic, as subreddits group posts, so people can find the discussions on topics they care about.
Could live at /v/community-name.
There could be a community around nutrition, another for software engineering, a meta community for Veritula, etc.
Ben could have his own community to build his Wikipedia competitor.

#6073·​Dennis HackethalOP revised 28 days ago·​AI-assisted·​Original #4652·​2 pending criticisms

“Group or maybe even replace discussions” leaves open two different designs. Grouping adds a level above discussions. Replacing removes them and has to move what hangs off them, like chronicles, the timeline, embedding, and the MCP endpoint’s discussion tools. Until it picks one, it can’t be built.

#6072·​Dennis HackethalOP, 28 days ago·​AI-assisted·​Criticism

Veritula doesn’t have enough discussions yet to split into communities. There are few, and most have only a handful of people in them, so most communities would sit empty, and empty ones make the site look abandoned.

#6071·​Dennis HackethalOP, 28 days ago·​AI-assisted·​Criticism

#4652 doesn’t say what people can’t do now that a community would let them do. A discussion already gathers ideas on one topic, so Ben could start one for his Wikipedia competitor today. Without the problem communities would solve, there’s no way to judge the design.

#6070·​Dennis HackethalOP, 28 days ago·​AI-assisted·​Criticism

@tyler-mills I’ll leave it to you to see if this chart type would give V anything the tree doesn’t. Archiving this idea for now.

#6069·​Dennis HackethalOP, 28 days ago·​Archived

Tyler suggested (#3904) we use the chart type from Kialo:

Kialo chart

Could be a useful visualization in addition to trees.

Each top-level idea would be the center node, with its replies in segments around it. They’d be colored like the visual tree’s discs: the idea blue, criticisms red, and comments gray, solid if rationally adoptable and hollow if not.

Unlike Kialo, though, segments with the same parent would all be the same size: they’d split their parent’s arc equally between them.

#6067·​Dennis HackethalOP revised 28 days ago·​AI-assisted·​Original #5730·​1 pending criticismArchived

#6063 doesn’t say what the chart would show that the visual tree doesn’t. Since #3904, the tree has come to do what Tyler asked for there: every reply is a node, criticisms are red, and edges to pending criticisms light up, so you can see at a glance which threads are still open. Without a problem the tree leaves unsolved, there’s no way to tell whether the chart is worth building or how it should look.

#6066·​Dennis HackethalOP, 28 days ago·​AI-assisted·​CriticismArchived

Gray for both non-pending criticisms and neutral comments makes them look alike, though a criticism that’s been addressed is still part of the argument and a comment never was. The visual tree’s discs keep them apart: criticisms are red and comments gray, solid if rationally adoptable and hollow if not.

#6065·​Dennis HackethalOP, 28 days ago·​AI-assisted·​CriticismArchived

Tyler suggested (#3904) we use the chart type from Kialo:

Kialo chart

Could be a useful visualization in addition to trees.

Each top-level idea would be the center node. Then red segments around it for pending criticisms. Gray for non-pending criticisms and neutral comments.

Unlike Kialo, though, segments with the same parent would all be the same size: they’d split their parent’s arc equally between them.

#6063·​Dennis HackethalOP revised 28 days ago·​AI-assisted·​Original #5730·​3 pending criticismsArchived

Segments can’t all be the same size on their circle and still sit within their parent’s arc. Say an idea has two criticisms, which split the first circle in half. If one gets a single reply and the other gets five, each of the six segments on the second circle takes a sixth of it, so the five replies span five sixths of the circle, well past their parent’s half. The chart would then no longer show what replies to what.

#6062·​Dennis HackethalOP, 28 days ago·​AI-assisted·​CriticismArchived

Each reply answers one idea, so addressing an idea’s pending criticisms directly is always the quickest way to rehabilitate it: one new criticism for each. Going further down the tree never takes fewer, so there’s no shorter path to show. What helps is going through them one at a time, which the guide now does (#2628).

#6061·​Dennis HackethalOP, 28 days ago·​AI-assisted·​CriticismArchived

Done, live now. Every idea with pending criticisms has “Rehabilitate” under it, which opens that idea’s guide, and “Guide” in the navbar goes through all of yours, starting with the ideas closest to being adoptable. Either way, it’s one pending criticism at a time: you can criticize it, revise the idea, move on, or skip. Moving on is the abandoning from #4089: it sets the idea aside for you alone, and the idea comes back if it gets new criticisms.

#6060·​Dennis HackethalOP, 28 days ago·​AI-assisted·​CriticismArchived