Search

Ideas that are…

Search Ideas


3952 ideas match your query.:

Popper says to prefer ideas that are better corroborated, more truthlike. I wrote about this recently, pasting it here:


Corroboration was meant to help us form rational preferences between ideas. From The Logic of Scientific Discovery (pp. 281-282):

We can sometimes rationally justify the preference for a theory in the light of its corroboration, that is, of the present state of the critical discussion of the competing theories, which are critically discussed and compared from the point of view of assessing their nearness to the truth (verisimilitude). The current state of this discussion may, in principle, be reported in the form of their degrees of corroboration.

Specifically, corroboration helps you form a rational preference between two theories that have both been shown to be false while there are no known alternatives. From Conjectures and Refutations (p. 318):

… even after t2 has been refuted in its turn, we can still say that it is better than t1, for although both have been shown to be false, the fact that t2 has withstood tests which t1 did not pass may be a good indication that the falsity-content of t1 exceeds that of t2 while its truth-content does not. Thus we may still give preference to t2, even after its falsification, because we have reason to think that it agrees better with the facts than did t1.

That “t2 has withstood tests which t1 did not pass” means t2 is better corroborated than t1.

#5253​·​Dennis Hackethal, 9 days ago​·​Criticized3

The idea ‘I’m located in a hemisphere’ is ‘easy to vary’ as to which hemisphere but it’s true, meaning it corresponds to reality.

HTV and correspondence are orthogonal.

#5252​·​Dennis Hackethal, 9 days ago​·​Criticism

Explanation A surviving criticism does not establish that explanation A is objective progress over explanation B. But the claim that one fatal flaw in explanation B is enough to reject explanation B does not depend on explanation A being objective progress. Rejecting explanation B and establishing explanation A as objective progress are separate claims.

#5251​·​Benjamin DaviesOP, 9 days ago​·​Criticism

The more HTV an explanation is, the more closely it corresponds to reality.

#5250​·​Benjamin DaviesOP, 9 days ago​·​Criticized3

That property is hard-to-vary-ness.

#5249​·​Benjamin DaviesOP, 9 days ago​·​Criticized1

A surviving the criticism does not show that A is progress over B. We could reject one error while moving even further from reality.

#5248​·​Benjamin DaviesOP, 9 days ago​·​CriticismCriticized1

One fatal flaw in B is enough to reject B. A does not also need to possess some opposite property that makes it the winner.

#5247​·​Benjamin DaviesOP, 9 days ago​·​Criticism

When we reject explanation B in favour of explanation A, there must be some property of the explanations that comprehensively distinguishes A as better than B.

#5246​·​Benjamin DaviesOP, 9 days ago​·​Criticized2

https://youtu.be/boWSKR7OrUw?t=627&si=V4UOiSZym6i0ZhjO

From 10:27 onwards, this video goes over a variety of diet related elements that affect sleep. Might be useful.

#5245​·​Benjamin Davies, 9 days ago

Something simple you could try is heavily dimming your computer and other devices and using strong red filters for the last few hours before bed.

Not just the standard night shift features, which are often far too weak. I mean making the screen properly red so that almost all of the blue and green light is removed.

You might be surprised by how dim you can make your devices while still being able to use them fine. You just need to give your eyes a minute to adjust. I routinely have my iPhone and MacBook on their dimmest settings.

Dimming or reddening the room lighting could help too. (Following up on #5243.)

#5244​·​Benjamin Davies, 9 days ago

This doesn't rule out blue light from other sources disturbing your ability to wind down and fall asleep.

#5243​·​Benjamin Davies, 9 days ago​·​Criticism

Becoming progressively less tired is compatible with physiological causes, such as those I mention in #5241.

#5242​·​Benjamin Davies, 9 days ago​·​Criticism

Diet isn't ruled out just by comparing a large dinner with an empty stomach before bed.

You've said that you often put off eating and struggle to eat as much as you intend to. If you're regularly under-eating or going long stretches without food, that may be keeping adrenaline and cortisol elevated into the evening, making it harder to wind down, fall asleep and stay asleep.

That could also explain why you're physically tired but still mentally alert and able to keep working at night.

#5241​·​Benjamin Davies, 9 days ago​·​CriticismCriticized1

I should write a blog post about intellectual dementia soon…

#5240​·​Dennis Hackethal, 10 days ago

PC 😳

#5239​·​Dennis Hackethal, 10 days ago

That said I still think you should go see a sleep doctor, Tyler.

#5238​·​Dennis Hackethal, 10 days ago

Found this article illuminating (emphasis mine):

The gradual loss of energy during the day produces a drive to sleep in order to restore that energy. This is known as the homeostatic sleep drive. If the homeostatic process were the only one involved, a person would wake up fully energized and then gradually wind down over the course of the day, like a battery losing power. This would mean an uneven level of alertness during the day, with dangerously low alertness in the afternoon and evening. To counterbalance this, the SCN also regulates alertness by what is known as the circadian process. As the day goes on, and energy winds down, the SCN compensates for this by sending a stronger alertness signal to the brain and body. This alertness signal reaches a peak in the two hours just before bedtime. This zone of maximum alertness is known as the “forbidden zone for sleep” since the alertness signal makes sleep nearly impossible during that zone. When the usual bedtime is reached, the SCN begins to turn down its alertness signal to allow the body to sleep.

The article is on “Non-24-Hour Sleep-Wake Disorder”. I’m obviously no doctor so don’t take anything I say as advice or diagnosis. But from what you’ve said, I wonder if you have that. I think I have the same issue.

The article goes into several causes you could look into. For example, it says exposure to blue light in the morning can help reset one’s internal clock. But that requires a special type of cell on the retina. If those cells don’t work properly, then as far as your internal clock is concerned, you’re effectively blind.

#5237​·​Dennis Hackethal, 10 days ago

You may be overstating the difficulty. IIRC you like rural America. Finding a quiet place to live should be doable, even in cities but especially in rural places. (Believe it or not I once stayed at an Airbnb in Tahoe that was TOO quiet to sleep. It was so quiet it kinda freaked me out. And that’s saying something because I love quiet.)

#5236​·​Dennis Hackethal, 10 days ago​·​CriticismCriticized2

Have you traveled internationally? I’m thinking specifically of flying west for a large distance.

For example, if I fly to the West coast from central Europe and I land at 12pm say. That’s 9 hours behind Europe. And then I try to stay up until 10pm or so. That’s nearly impossible. I’ve fallen asleep with the lights on.

Would be interesting if you still lay awake for an hour or so even when severely jet lagged.

#5235​·​Dennis Hackethal, 10 days ago

Isn’t this a criticism?

#5234​·​Dennis Hackethal, 10 days ago​·​Criticism

What’s wrong with using melatonin indefinitely?

AFAIK it creates no physical dependence, you don’t build a tolerance, and it’s cheap. What’s not to love?

#5233​·​Dennis Hackethal, 10 days ago​·​CriticismCriticized3

Shouldn’t this be a criticism?

#5232​·​Dennis Hackethal, 10 days ago​·​Criticism

Something I made the other day, recipe in the caption :) https://www.instagram.com/p/Db2DzFplBXq/?igsh=NTc4MTIwNjQ2YQ==

#5231​·​Dennis Hackethal, 10 days ago

Could you do meal prep for the week? Have meals ready in the freezer so you don’t need to cook every day.

#5230​·​Dennis Hackethal, 10 days ago

The cause of procrastination is a conflict between preferences. Part of you wants to take out the trash, another doesn’t. The solution is a common preference: a new option both parts of you prefer to their respective initial position.

Can you identify those parts within you?
Try brainstorming many new options on V. With any luck, you’ll find a new option both parts of you want without delay.

#5229​·​Dennis Hackethal, 10 days ago